Critics are divided on Blasphemous 2's story. Some praise its unique religious narrative and deep lore, while others find it cryptic and confusing. The game delves into themes of suffering, guilt, and redemption, but some critics feel it lacks clarity and can be tedious to follow. Overall, Blasphemous 2 offers an intriguing experience for players who enjoy immersive and cryptic storytelling, but may not be for those seeking a straightforward narrative.

Critics widely praise Blasphemous 2 for its intense combat, challenging boss fights, and diverse weapon choices, leading to a highly enjoyable gameplay experience. While some reviewers mentioned control issues and occasional frustrations, the majority agree that the game offers improved mechanics and a satisfying blend of Metroidvania and Souls-like elements. Overall, Blasphemous 2 delivers a rewarding and engaging experience for players.

Critics rave about Blasphemous 2's stunning pixel art style, detailed animations, and unique character designs, praising its grotesque beauty and immersive atmosphere. Despite a few criticisms about animated cutscenes and visual changes, the game's exceptional graphics and visual design shine through, showcasing a visually impressive and artistically rich gaming experience.

Critics raved about the outstanding sound design and music of Blasphemous 2, praising its Spanish guitars and orchestral numbers that perfectly complemented the game's action and atmosphere. The Flamenco-style score was highlighted as powerful and immersive, reminiscent of Castlevania titles. While some critics suggested adding more variety, the overall sentiment was overwhelmingly positive, with the majority applauding the melodic and immersive experience created by the soundtrack. The brilliant execution of the sound design, especially for the protagonist and enemies, further solidified the game's audio as a standout feature.

Critics rave about the high-quality voice acting in Blasphemous 2, praising its impact on the game's atmosphere and character depth. While some find the FromSoftware-like style engaging, others may see it as overdone. The addition of a Spanish voice track is lauded for adding authenticity and appeal to a wider audience. Overall, the voice acting is a standout feature that enriches the gaming experience, with minor criticism lacking specific examples.

Critics laud Blasphemous 2's strong technical performance on PlayStation 5 and PC, praising smooth gameplay and optimization. Minor issues like bugs on Nintendo Switch don't detract from the overall positive experience. Developers have clearly prioritized a polished and enjoyable gaming experience across platforms.

Critics generally praise Blasphemous 2 for its challenging gameplay and replay value, with features like customization options, secrets, and exploration cited as strong points. Some critics mention concerns about the game's length and certain gameplay elements, but overall, the consensus is positive for its ability to keep players engaged and satisfied with hidden content discovery.