Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree

The opinions of the critics regarding the Story of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree are overwhelmingly positive, with the majority of them praising the expansion for its rich narrative, deep lore, and intriguing character developments. Critics like Checkpoint Gaming and Meristation commend the game for its rich lore and intricate world design, while GameMAG and Impulsegamer highlight the compelling narrative and new character introductions that add depth to the overall storytelling. The expansion is noted for providing answers to previous mysteries, expanding the game's universe, and offering a narrative focus on characters related to the main game, as mentioned by Meristation. On the flip side, some critics, such as Dot Esports and TheSixthAxis, express concerns about the story being confusing, raising more questions than answers, and feeling lackluster or underwhelming in certain aspects. Dot Esports specifically mentions the need for lore videos to fully grasp the context, indicating a potential barrier for some players to engage with the narrative. TheSixthAxis criticizes the final boss as disappointing and the ending as unsatisfying, highlighting areas where the storytelling may have fallen short for certain reviewers. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the Story of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree is a significant and positive addition to the game, expanding on the base game's lore, introducing new mysteries and characters, and providing a compelling narrative experience. The storytelling is praised for its depth, thematic scope, and character development, as noted by PC Gamer. Despite some criticisms regarding clarity and pacing, the majority of reviewers appreciate the expansion's contribution to the overarching narrative and world-building of Elden Ring. The positive reception from critics underscores the strength of the storytelling in Shadow of the Erdtree and its ability to captivate players with its enigmatic and immersive narrative.

The majority of the critics had overwhelmingly positive opinions about the gameplay of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, praising various aspects of the expansion. Critics like Atomix, But Why Tho?, and GameMAG highlighted the introduction of new elements such as challenging combat, diverse character progression systems, and fresh exploration experiences. The addition of new weapons, spells, armor, and enemies was well-received, with Game Revolution noting the increased difficulty but manageable boss fights, adding depth to the gameplay. The expansion was commended for offering engaging combat encounters, innovative mechanics like Scadutree Fragments and Revered Spirit Ashes, and a significant amount of content for players to explore, as noted by GamingBolt and Impulsegamer. While the majority of critics praised the gameplay of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, there were some minor criticisms raised by a few reviewers. The SixthAxis pointed out that some new mechanics like Scadutree Fragments and Revered Spirit Ash did not seamlessly integrate with the overall game design, leading to a sense of forced progression for players. Additionally, Gamepressure mentioned that the difficulty level of the expansion might be too high for some players, potentially impacting their overall enjoyment of the game. However, these criticisms were in the minority compared to the overwhelmingly positive feedback from the majority of critics. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree delivers a highly satisfying gameplay experience that builds upon the strengths of the base game. The expansion introduces a wealth of new content, including challenging boss battles, diverse combat encounters, and intricate exploration opportunities, as highlighted by critics like Meristation and LevelUp. The addition of new progression mechanics, weapons, spells, and enemies enrich the gameplay experience, offering players a fresh and engaging adventure in the world of Elden Ring. Despite a few minor criticisms, the general sentiment is that the gameplay of the expansion is very good, providing both familiar elements for fans of the series and exciting new features to explore and master, making it a worthy addition to the Elden Ring universe.

The majority of critics unanimously praised the Graphics and Visual Design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, highlighting its stunning and immersive qualities. Critics like Atomix, Checkpoint Gaming, and Meristation appreciated the hauntingly beautiful and diverse environments, detailed character models, and creative architectural designs present in the game. The introduction of new biomes, dungeons, enemies, and armor designs, as mentioned by Atomix, added freshness while maintaining the signature aesthetic of Elden Ring. The game's intricate world design, vibrant colors, and impressive details, as noted by Dot Esports and GamersRD, contributed to a visually captivating experience. Furthermore, the level design, as commended by Metro GameCentral and Noisy Pixel, provided non-linear exploration opportunities and hidden secrets, enhancing the overall visual appeal. Despite the overwhelmingly positive reception, a few critics pointed out some issues with the Graphics and Visual Design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. Vandal highlighted technical performance problems like rendering issues, which affected the overall experience for some players. TechRadar Gaming also mentioned performance issues on both console and PC, particularly in dense locations. Additionally, XboxEra noted that while the game featured beautiful vistas and diverse locales, the texture work could appear rough up close, potentially detracting from the otherwise impressive visual presentation. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The game was praised for its stunning environments, intricate details, diverse biomes, and creative character and enemy designs. Critics appreciated the immersive atmosphere, verticality, and level design that enhanced exploration and gameplay experiences. While some minor technical issues were mentioned by a few critics, the majority agreed that the visual design of the game was exceptional and contributed significantly to the overall enjoyment of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The game's ability to maintain the signature FromSoftware style while introducing new elements was widely celebrated, making it a visually impressive and immersive experience for players across different platforms.

The majority of critics praised the Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree for its exceptional quality. Atomix commended the atmospheric sound design, highlighting the classic choirs during battles and the blend of ambient sounds and melodic moments that enhance the immersive audio experience. Checkpoint Gaming noted the distinct scores accompanying each area, filled with haunting melodies that build tension and anticipation. GamersRD appreciated the religious themes in the soundtrack that enhance boss battles, with dynamic music changes during boss phases, contributing to the immersive experience. Impulsegamer and Meristation both highlighted the impressive sound design that elevates the overall gameplay experience, while Noisy Pixel and PC Gamer praised the beautiful and immersive music that enhances the atmosphere of the Shadow Realm. On the negative side, there were no significant criticisms mentioned by the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The absence of any negative feedback suggests a high level of consistency and quality in this aspect of the game, as highlighted by reviewers such as Gamepressure, who mentioned the top-notch audio-visual experience, and Vandal, who praised the new orchestral music for fitting the dark fantasy theme of the game. Overall, the consensus among the critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The combination of epic orchestral soundtracks, dynamic music changes during boss encounters, and immersive sound design was highly praised by reviewers across different platforms. The seamless integration of music with gameplay elements, such as enhancing boss battles and setting the mood for different encounters, contributed to a captivating and engaging audio experience for players. The lack of any notable negative feedback underscores the excellence of the sound design and music in Elden Ring, solidifying its reputation as a standout feature in the game that significantly enhances the overall gaming experience.

Summary unavailable

In terms of technical performance on PS5, Elden Ring seems to have a mix of positives and negatives. Critics like GamersRD and Impulsegamer reported stable performance with no specific issues mentioned, highlighting a smooth experience for players on this platform. Dot Esports also noted minor bugs and collision issues, which, while present, were not considered game-breaking. However, Meristation pointed out frame rate issues occurring more frequently than in the base game, and Metro GameCentral highlighted glitches with ground textures and unclear instructions, which could potentially affect the overall experience for PS5 players. Moving on to the PC platform, the technical performance of Elden Ring seems to be more varied. Gamepressure and GINX TV mentioned performance issues impacting frame rates during boss fights, while Vandal and Wccftech reported issues with frame rate drops, freezes, and popping, indicating technical shortcomings that need improvement. GamingBolt encountered performance issues at 4K resolution on a high-end PC, requiring a resolution decrease for stability. This inconsistency in performance across different PC setups suggests that optimization may be a concern for some players. For Xbox Series X, the feedback on technical performance was generally positive. TheXboxHub reported no slowdown or stuttering even with high particle effects, showcasing a smooth gameplay experience on the Series X console. TechRadar Gaming mentioned occasional visual oddities and performance dips, with framerate dropping in dense areas but still deemed the game overall playable. XboxEra highlighted stable expansion gameplay with no major bugs or disconnects, although some framerate struggles were noted on powerful PCs. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the technical performance of Elden Ring across different gaming platforms is mixed. While some platforms like PS5 and Xbox Series X received praise for stable performance and smooth gameplay experiences, others like PC faced challenges with performance issues, frame rate drops, and optimization concerns. The feedback suggests that there is room for improvement, particularly in addressing technical shortcomings and optimizing the game for a more consistent experience across all platforms.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple reviewers regarding the Replay Value of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, it is evident that the majority of critics found the game to offer exceptional replayability. Critics such as Atomix, Checkpoint Gaming, and Impulsegamer highlighted the expansion's provision of new challenges, secrets, customization options, and high-quality side content, encouraging multiple playthroughs. The vertical exploration, complex map design, diverse weapon options, and significant amount of content, as noted by Meristation and Gamepressure, further contribute to the game's positive replay value. On the other hand, some critics did mention a few drawbacks related to the replay value of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. GINX TV expressed that exploration and endgame content felt less rewarding after defeating mainline bosses, with certain areas appearing empty, potentially leading to a sense of hitting a ceiling prematurely. PC Invasion also noted that while the DLC offers unique progression systems and challenging gameplay, some rewards may feel underwhelming for players with maxed-out weapons and builds, potentially impacting the motivation for replaying the game. Overall, the consensus among the critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the replay value of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The game is praised for its vast amount of content, new challenges, weapons, enemies, and optional bosses, making it highly replayable for players who enjoy thorough exploration, character development, and uncovering hidden secrets. With over 50 hours of gameplay, rich in secrets, multiple paths, and hidden areas, as mentioned by PC Gamer, Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree stands out among other expansions in terms of providing a rewarding and engaging experience for players seeking multiple playthroughs. The variety of content, complexity of level design, and new gameplay elements introduced in the expansion, as highlighted by Vandal and Wccftech, further enhance the game's replay value, making it a worthwhile investment for fans of the genre.