Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree

The majority of critics praised the story of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree for its depth, mystery, and expansion of the game's lore. Critics like Atomix and But Why Tho? appreciated the cryptic and enigmatic storytelling that focused on player interpretation and hidden details, adding new insights into the world and characters. Checkpoint Gaming and GameMAG highlighted the rich lore, intricate world design, and compelling narrative that immersed players in the Shadow Realm, while GamersRD and Impulsegamer found the narrative to be cryptic yet engaging, with new characters like Mikella intertwining with existing stories, providing a sense of narrative depth and importance. On the other hand, some critics, such as Dot Esports and TheSixthAxis, found the story of Shadow of the Erdtree to be confusing, convoluted, and lacking in clarity, with unresolved questions that required additional resources like lore videos for full context. TheSixthAxis specifically mentioned the final boss as disappointing and the ending as unsatisfying and underwhelming. Noisy Pixel also noted that the story took a backseat to combat and exploration, potentially disengaging some players who prefer a more straightforward narrative experience. Overall, despite some mixed opinions, the consensus among the majority of critics leans towards a positive evaluation of the story in Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The expansion was commended for its ability to deepen the lore, introduce new characters and storylines, and provide a compelling narrative experience that expanded on the base game's universe. Critics like PC Gamer praised the masterfully embedded storytelling that challenged assumptions and expanded thematic scope, while GAMINGbible highlighted the important narrative developments that shed light on dark themes within the world. The overall sentiment suggests that while there were some criticisms regarding clarity and pacing, the majority of critics found the story to be a significant and enriching addition to the Elden Ring experience.

The majority of critics praised the gameplay of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, highlighting various positive aspects. Atomix commended the expansion for building upon the accessible mechanics of Elden Ring and introducing new elements like a group of warriors, enhancing the exploration experience in the Shadow Realm. But Why Tho? appreciated the mix of familiar and fresh experiences through new blessings, equipment, and challenging boss battles. Checkpoint Gaming and GameMAG both emphasized the challenging combat and character progression systems exclusive to the Shadow Realm, with the latter mentioning strategic approaches and perseverance as key elements. GamersRD and Impulsegamer lauded the new region with challenging enemies, bosses, and dungeons, offering a significant amount of exploration and content. On the other hand, some critics pointed out certain negatives regarding the gameplay of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The SixthAxis expressed concerns about the implementation of new mechanics like Scadutree Fragments and Revered Spirit Ash, suggesting that they didn't align well with the game's overall design. They noted that players felt heavily incentivized to gather upgrades before engaging with the world, potentially disrupting the natural flow of gameplay. Game Revolution mentioned that while the game introduced new elements like weapons, spells, and enemies, it lacked a super challenging boss equivalent to Malenia, which might have impacted the overall difficulty balance for some players. Despite some minor criticisms, the overall consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the gameplay of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The game was praised for its engaging combat, challenging boss battles, new weapons, spells, and character progression systems. Critics like MMORPG.com highlighted the rewarding combat system, while LevelUp appreciated the essence of the base game being maintained with quality of life improvements. The game's dense exploration, challenging encounters, and variety of playstyles were also commended by reviewers like Hooked Gamers and Vandal. The general sentiment is that the expansion successfully builds upon the strengths of Elden Ring, offering a compelling and satisfying gameplay experience for both new and experienced players.

The majority of critics unanimously praised the Graphics and Visual Design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, highlighting various positive aspects. Critics like Atomix, Checkpoint Gaming, and GameMAG appreciated the hauntingly beautiful and diverse environments, detailed character and enemy models, and creative architectural design. The game was commended for its stunning visuals, vibrant colors, intricate details, and immersive ambiance, with areas like the Shadow Realm offering a mix of eerie and beautiful landscapes. The expansion was lauded for introducing new biomes, dungeons, enemies, armor designs, and visually interesting areas to explore, as noted by Impulsegamer and Meristation. The level design, verticality, and intricate details in the Land of Shadow were also highlighted by critics such as PlayStation Country and Game Revolution, enhancing the sense of exploration satisfaction. However, some critics did mention a few negatives regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. Vandal pointed out technical performance issues like rendering problems, while TechRadar Gaming highlighted performance issues on both console and PC, especially in dense locations. XboxEra noted that texture work could appear rough up close, indicating a minor flaw in the overall visual presentation. These criticisms, though present, were not prevalent among the majority of reviewers and did not significantly detract from the overall positive reception of the game's Graphics and Visual Design. Overall, the consensus among the critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The game was widely praised for its exceptional art direction, breathtaking vistas, stunning visuals, and diverse environments that captivated players. The unique and familiar aesthetic of Elden Ring was maintained while introducing new elements that enhanced the overall visual experience, as highlighted by But Why Tho? and GamersRD. The intricate details, impressive world design, and visually stunning areas in the Land of Shadow were particularly celebrated, with critics like LevelUp and Noisy Pixel emphasizing the expansiveness and beauty of the world design. Despite minor technical issues mentioned by a few critics, the majority agreed that Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree excelled in delivering a visually striking and immersive experience that set a high standard in the gaming industry.

The opinions of the critics unanimously praise the Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. Atomix commends the atmospheric sound design, blending ambient sounds and melodic moments, with classic choirs during battles, enhancing the immersive experience. Checkpoint Gaming highlights the distinct scores in each area, filled with haunting melodies that build tension, while Dot Esports mentions the epic orchestral soundtrack enhancing boss encounters. GamersRD appreciates the religious themes in the soundtrack that dynamically change during boss battles, adding to the immersive experience. Impulsegamer and Meristation both emphasize the impressive sound design that elevates the overall experience, with Impulsegamer specifically mentioning the melancholy score complementing the Land of Shadow's atmosphere. Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, there are no significant negative comments regarding the Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree from the critics. The absence of any critical feedback suggests a high level of consistency and quality in this aspect of the game. This lack of negative criticism indicates a strong cohesion and effectiveness in the sound design and music, contributing positively to the overall gameplay experience. In conclusion, the majority of critics, including Gamepressure, GamingBolt, and Noisy Pixel, agree that the Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree are exceptional, with praises for the immersive soundscapes, impactful music, and dynamic elements enhancing boss encounters and setting the mood for different gameplay segments. The positive reception from a variety of critics across different platforms underscores the universal acclaim for the game's audio aspects. The consensus among the critics is overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the success of Elden Ring in delivering a top-notch audio-visual experience that elevates the overall immersion and enjoyment of the game.

Summary unavailable

In terms of the technical performance on different gaming platforms for Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, there are some positive aspects highlighted by the critics. Gamepressure on PC mentioned stable performance with high graphics settings and no crashes reported, indicating a smooth experience for PC players. The Xbox Series X also received praise, with TheXboxHub noting no slowdown or stuttering even in high particle effect scenarios, showcasing the console's capability to handle the game seamlessly. On the flip side, there were some negative aspects pointed out by the reviewers regarding technical performance. GINX TV on PC highlighted performance issues during boss fights impacting frame rates, while Vandal mentioned issues with performance and popping, indicating technical shortcomings on the PC platform. GamingBolt encountered performance issues at 4K resolution on a high-end PC, necessitating a resolution downgrade for stability, showcasing potential optimization challenges on the PC platform. Overall, the consensus among the critics regarding the technical performance of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree is mixed. While some platforms like Xbox Series X were praised for stable performance and smooth gameplay experiences, others like PC faced challenges with performance issues, frame rate drops, and occasional freezes. The PS5 platform had a mix of positive and negative feedback, with some critics noting minor bugs and frame rate issues. The general sentiment leans towards the need for improvements and potential fixes through patches to enhance the technical performance across all platforms, as highlighted by critics like Dot Esports and Impulsegamer.

The opinions of the critics overwhelmingly highlight the strong replay value of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. Critics like Atomix, Checkpoint Gaming, and Impulsegamer praise the game for offering new challenges, customization options, and high-quality side content, encouraging multiple playthroughs. The vertical exploration, complex map design, and diverse weapon options mentioned by Meristation further enhance the replayability of the game. Additionally, the vast amount of content, including new upgrades, weapons, armor sets, and multiple endings, as noted by GamersRD and MMORPG.com, contribute to the positive replay value of the expansion. On the flip side, a few critics express minor drawbacks that could impact the overall replay experience of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. MeuPlayStation mentions the lack of new trophies affecting the exploration experience by not providing guidance on missed content. GINX TV and PC Invasion point out that some areas may feel empty or rewards underwhelming for players with maxed-out weapons and builds, potentially leading to a sense of hitting a ceiling in terms of progression. These criticisms suggest that while the game excels in providing content for multiple playthroughs, there are areas that could be improved to maintain player engagement throughout. Overall, the consensus among the critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the replay value of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. The majority of reviewers commend the expansion for offering a significant amount of content, new challenges, weapons, and enemies, making it highly replayable for players looking to explore different playstyles, uncover secrets, and face tough adversaries. The variety of gameplay elements, intricate level design, and engaging systems introduced in the expansion contribute to a rich and rewarding experience that encourages players to revisit the world of Elden Ring multiple times. Critics like Gamepressure and Vandal highlight the complexity of level design and variety of content as key factors in enhancing the replay value of the game, solidifying its status as a standout expansion with excellent replayability.