Critics unanimously praise the engaging story of My Time at Sandrock, highlighting its depth, post-apocalyptic town premise, and satisfying character development. With no negative feedback, the story is deemed well-crafted and enjoyable, drawing players in with its narrative and world-building. Overall, the game's story receives high acclaim for its immersive experience and positive reception from reviewers.

Critics generally praise My Time at Sandrock for its diverse and engaging gameplay mechanics, including robust crafting, open-ended farming, and satisfying resource management. Some critics note technical errors and tedious crafting elements, but overall, the game offers a satisfying experience with positive feedback on its activities and quests.

Critics have mixed opinions on the Graphics and Visual Design of My Time at Sandrock. Some praise the gorgeous and vibrant graphics that bring life to the desert landscape, while others criticize issues like low-quality character models and performance problems. Overall, the game's visuals have strengths like vibrant character designs and a unique setting, but also suffer from technical shortcomings and lack of polish, leading to divided views among critics.

Critics praise the sound design and music of My Time at Sandrock for enhancing the game's atmosphere and immersing players in its world. Positive feedback includes the voiced dialog adding life to the town and fitting each character well. Some critics mention minor issues like inconsistent audio mixing, but overall, the consensus is that the sound design and music contribute to a cozy and enjoyable experience, making the game more immersive and enjoyable.

Critics mostly praise the voice acting in My Time at Sandrock for enhancing immersion and character depth. Some critics have reservations, but overall, the positive feedback outweighs the negatives. While not a standout feature, the voice acting effectively brings characters to life and enhances the overall gaming experience.

Critics slam Nintendo Switch version of My Time at Sandrock for framerate, graphical, and loading issues. PlayStation 5 version faces technical hiccups expected to be fixed with patches. Xbox Series X version has fixable performance issues. PC version shows technical imperfections but performs decently.

Critics generally praise My Time at Sandrock for its wide variety of engaging activities and content that keep players hooked. The game's satisfying gameplay loop and customizable play styles are highlighted, along with the addition of a cooperative multiplayer mode. While some critics mention there may be better alternatives available, overall, the consensus is that the game offers plenty of content, rewards, and progression elements that enhance its replay value and keep players coming back for more.