Sonic Frontiers

The opinions of the critics regarding the story of Sonic Frontiers are quite varied. Several critics, such as DualShockers, Push Square, and Game Informer, praise the story for capturing the true spirit of the characters, its somber tone, emotional moments, and the introduction of new characters. They consider it a refreshing and compelling narrative that delves into Sonic's past and provides some of the best character moments in the series history. These positive opinions highlight the depth and emotional resonance of the plot, as well as its ability to engage and resonate with players. On the other hand, there are critics like Slant Magazine, Softpedia, and Dexerto who have negative opinions about the story. They describe it as laughable, lacking depth, and uninspiring. These critics feel disengaged from the narrative and find it confusing, unfinished, and anchored down by technical issues. Their negative opinions suggest that the story fails to deliver a satisfying and cohesive experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is mixed. While some critics appreciate the story's emotional weight, engaging narrative, and contextual callbacks to previous adventures, others find it confusing, repetitive, and lacking in depth. The positive opinions highlight the strengths of the story, including its somber tone, character development, and exploration of themes. However, the negative opinions suggest that the story may not resonate with all players and may suffer from technical issues and a lack of depth. It is clear that the story of Sonic Frontiers has its strengths and weaknesses, and players' enjoyment may vary depending on their preferences and expectations.

The majority of the critics praised the gameplay of Sonic Frontiers, with many highlighting its open-world design and traversal mechanics. Critics such as Push Square and Guardian compared the gameplay to Marvel's Spider-Man, emphasizing the enjoyable exploration and traversal mechanics. The inclusion of the new Cyloop mechanic was also highly praised, with critics like GameGrin and Impulsegamer noting its effectiveness in both puzzle solving and combat. The gameplay was described as fast-paced and exhilarating, with Dexerto and GameSkinny highlighting the fun and fast combat. The ability to explore and complete challenges at their own pace was also appreciated by Switch Player. The open-world format was seen as a successful experiment, making the gameplay less frustrating and allowing for exploration and diversions, as mentioned by GamesBeat. The inclusion of mini-bosses and varied challenges added variety to the gameplay, as noted by Push Square and Softpedia. However, there were some criticisms regarding the gameplay of Sonic Frontiers. Screen Rant mentioned inconsistent gameplay mechanics and confusion for the player when determining which direction to move. Slant Magazine criticized the control scheme, describing it as cumbersome, and PC Gamer mentioned issues with controls and fighting sequences. Some critics, such as But Why Tho?, felt that the game lacked the heart and coolness of previous Sonic adventures. Repetition and lack of challenge in certain areas were also mentioned as drawbacks by Switch Player, which affected the replay value. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the gameplay of Sonic Frontiers is very good. The positive aspects of the gameplay, such as the open-world design, traversal mechanics, and the inclusion of the Cyloop mechanic, were widely praised. The gameplay was described as enjoyable, engaging, and fun, with various challenges, collectibles, and mini-games to complete. The combination of traditional Sonic elements with open-world exploration and questing was seen as a fresh and surprising experience by TheSixthAxis. The gameplay received high marks for its fast-paced running, cool stunts, and comprehensive combat mechanics, as noted by Game Informer. Despite some criticisms regarding inconsistent mechanics, control issues, and a lack of challenge in certain areas, the overall sentiment is that the gameplay of Sonic Frontiers is a blast and a marked improvement for the Sonic franchise.

In terms of the graphics and visual design of Sonic Frontiers, there are several positive aspects that critics have highlighted. DualShockers commends the game for its massive landscapes on the Starfall Islands, creating a sense of exploration. GameGrin praises the beautiful-looking game with its diverse environments, including hills, valleys, waterfalls, and different themes for each island. IGN Portugal also mentions the varied graphical styles and densely populated islands with distinct enemies, adding to the visual appeal. Impulsegamer appreciates the melancholic vibe, occasional moody weather, and relaxing soundtrack, which contribute to the overall atmosphere of the game. However, there are also some negative opinions regarding the graphics and visual design of Sonic Frontiers. Critics such as Screen Rant, But Why Tho?, Slant Magazine, Gaming Age, Switch Player, GameSkinny, and CGMagazine express disappointment with certain aspects. They mention that the open world can feel generic, dull, and lacking in vibrancy. The visuals may lack detail, blending between elements can be strange, and the environments may suffer from constant pop-in issues. Dexerto, Guardian, and GAMES.CH criticize glitches, unkempt elements, and underwhelming presentation in cutscenes. Video Chums and TheXboxHub point out jarring visual pop-in, especially on certain platforms. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed regarding the graphics and visual design of Sonic Frontiers. While there are positive remarks about the vast landscapes, diverse environments, and varied graphical styles, there are also criticisms about generic open world design, lack of vibrancy, and constant pop-in issues. Some critics appreciate the melancholic atmosphere and engaging exploration, while others feel that the game falls short in comparison to modern open-world games. However, there is a general appreciation for the effort put into creating visually appealing Sonic stages and the overall next-gen graphics.

In terms of the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Frontiers, the majority of critics had positive opinions. Push Square, for instance, praised the music as the best in the series, with a diverse range of genres including sombre suites, banging electronic tunes, classic butt-rock music, and even lo-fi beats for the fishing mini-game. COGconnected also commended the music, describing it as excellent and capturing the lonely, ancient vibe of the game with somber scores and frantic beats. TheSixthAxis went as far as calling the soundtrack phenomenal, highlighting its mix of synthwave, orchestral work, classic Sonic-pop, and heavy metal. Variety also lauded the game's music, noting the gorgeous and smooth piano melodies during exploration and the edgy pop-punk tunes during boss fights. On the other hand, there were a few critics who expressed negative opinions about the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Frontiers. Softpedia, for example, found the music forgettable, except for the boss fights, and criticized the metal themes for not fitting the game's profile. Game Informer, while generally positive about the music, mentioned that it felt ripped straight out of an anime credits sequence, which may not appeal to all players. GAMES.CH, although not specifically commenting on the music, criticized the voice acting, particularly Sonic's English voice actor. Overall, the consensus among the critics leans towards the positive side. The majority of reviewers praised the music in Sonic Frontiers, highlighting its diversity, capturing of different moods, and its ability to enhance the gameplay experience. Critics such as Push Square, COGconnected, and TheSixthAxis were particularly impressed with the soundtrack, while Variety appreciated the music's ability to suit the different environments and moments in the game. While there were a few negative comments, they were outweighed by the positive opinions, making the overall sentiment towards the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Frontiers predominantly positive.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple videogame reviewers regarding the voice acting in Sonic Frontiers, it is evident that there is a mix of positive and negative feedback. Push Square commends the voice performances for being less cartoony than usual, contributing to the sombre tone of the game. They specifically highlight the new character Sage and her relationship with Robotnik as particularly praiseworthy. This positive feedback suggests that the voice acting successfully enhances the overall atmosphere and depth of the game. However, not all critics share the same sentiment. Softpedia criticizes the voice acting, simply stating that it is "bad." This negative feedback indicates that the voice performances may have fallen short in terms of quality or believability. Additionally, GAMES.CH criticizes Sonic's English voice actor specifically, suggesting that there may have been issues with the portrayal of the iconic character. These criticisms highlight potential weaknesses in the voice acting that may have detracted from the overall experience. On the other hand, Dexerto mentions Sonic's voice standing out and sounding like he finally hit something akin to hedgehog puberty. This comment suggests that there may have been improvements or changes in Sonic's voice acting that were positively received. Movies Games and Tech also express a positive opinion, stating that the voice acting in Sonic Frontiers is on-point. This further supports the notion that there are aspects of the voice performances that were well-executed and effectively conveyed the intended emotions and characterizations. Taking into account the mixed opinions, it can be concluded that the overall consensus among the critics regarding the voice acting in Sonic Frontiers is somewhat divided. While there are positive aspects highlighted, such as the contributions to the sombre tone and the portrayal of new characters like Sage, there are also criticisms regarding the quality and specific portrayals. It is important to note that the positive feedback from Push Square and Forbes, who commend the voice acting for enhancing the overall experience and storytelling, suggests that there are redeeming qualities to be found. However, the negative feedback from Softpedia and GAMES.CH indicates that improvements could have been made in certain areas. Ultimately, individual preferences and expectations may play a significant role in shaping one's perception of the voice acting in Sonic Frontiers.

In terms of the technical performance on the PS5, there are some positive aspects mentioned by the critics. DualShockers notes that the game has impressive load times, while CGMagazine mentions that it loads fairly quickly on the PlayStation 5 and offers a solid 60fps presentation in performance mode. GamesBeat also adds that the game runs well on the PS5, maintaining around 60 fps in Performance Mode. These positive comments indicate that the PS5 version of Sonic Frontiers provides a smooth and enjoyable gaming experience with minimal technical issues. However, there are also negative aspects mentioned by the critics regarding the PS5 version. Several critics, such as Slant Magazine, Daily Star, and Game Informer, highlight the game's lack of polish and unfinished feel. They mention issues of graphics popping in and out on the screen, which can be distracting and affect the overall immersion. Dexerto further criticizes the technical problems, including pop-in issues and a wonky camera that makes it difficult to see enemies. These negative comments suggest that the technical performance on the PS5 version of Sonic Frontiers leaves much to be desired. Moving on to the Nintendo Switch version, Screen Rant and Gaming Age express their dissatisfaction with the technical performance. Screen Rant mentions that performance and design choices weigh down the game, while Gaming Age specifically criticizes the technical issues, especially in the open world. These negative comments indicate that the Switch version of Sonic Frontiers may suffer from performance issues and technical limitations, potentially impacting the overall gameplay experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sonic Frontiers has mixed technical performance across different gaming platforms. While the PS5 version receives some positive comments regarding load times and smooth gameplay, it also faces criticism for pop-in issues and a lack of polish. The Nintendo Switch version, on the other hand, is consistently criticized for its technical issues and performance limitations. Despite these drawbacks, some critics mention that the technical deficiencies do not significantly impact the gameplay experience, suggesting that Sonic Frontiers still manages to provide an enjoyable experience despite its technical shortcomings.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of Sonic Frontiers are varied, with some positive aspects highlighted. GameGrin mentions the ability to rechallenge levels and the presence of different enemies and themes on each island, which adds to the replay value. But Why Tho? praises the game for offering a lot to do with hundreds of objectives and currencies, making the progression through the game satisfying. IGN Portugal also mentions the replay value provided by secrets to discover and explore on the open-zone island. Softpedia adds that the game has varied challenges and collectibles, contributing to its replay value. These positive aspects indicate that Sonic Frontiers offers a range of activities and content that can keep players engaged and interested in replaying the game. However, there are also negative aspects mentioned by some critics that affect the replay value of Sonic Frontiers. Switch Player criticizes the lack of challenge, repetitive levels, and linear paths in Cyber Space, which can diminish the desire to replay the game. They also mention that collectibles are not hidden well and achieving S-rank times is easy, which can reduce the motivation for replaying. PC Gamer points out that while the game has a progression system with collectibles, the world itself doesn't feel worth exploring, and traversal and stunts are more rewarding than collecting items. These negative aspects suggest that certain elements of the game may not provide enough incentive for players to replay it. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sonic Frontiers offers some replay value, but it is not without its flaws. The game's collectathon elements, varied challenges, and objectives provide positive aspects that can contribute to replayability. Critics such as Game Informer also highlight the satisfaction of efficiently speedrunning branching stages and collecting Chaos Emerald Vault Keys. However, negative aspects such as repetitive levels, lack of challenge, and uninteresting world design are mentioned by critics like Switch Player and PC Gamer. Despite these flaws, Cubed3 emphasizes that there is plenty of content and never a dull moment, making it a game that every Sonic fan needs to play. Overall, while Sonic Frontiers offers some replay value, it may not fully meet the expectations of all players due to its shortcomings.