Critics overwhelmingly praise the compelling and well-written storyline of Star Ocean: The Second Story R, with unexpected twists and interesting character encounters. While some critics mention RPG tropes and pacing issues, the majority find the story enjoyable, highlighting its strengths in character relationships and storytelling. Positive reviews from various sources underscore the game's narrative quality, making it a standout feature despite some minor criticisms.

Critics rave about the gameplay of Star Ocean: The Second Story R, praising its improved combat system with new mechanics and strategic depth. Customization options and exploration are lauded for adding to the game's enjoyment. Some critics note minor drawbacks like clunky combat and tedious dungeon design, but overall, the game's core mechanics have stood the test of time and provide an engaging experience with freedom and depth.

Critics overwhelmingly praised Star Ocean: The Second Story R for its stunning blend of 2D sprites and 3D backgrounds, with the HD-2D style breathing new life into the game's visuals. While some minor criticisms were raised, like characters feeling out of place and texture pop-in issues on the Switch version, the game was hailed for its deep graphical overhaul and stable frame rates. Overall, the remake was a visual success, impressing critics and creating an immersive world true to its original charm.

Critics praised the enhanced soundtrack and voice acting in Star Ocean: The Second Story R, with high marks for the full orchestra and multiple language options. While some noted issues like lack of variation in the soundtrack and voice acting context, overall, the Sound Design and Music were seen as positive additions to the game's atmosphere and experience.

The voice acting in Star Ocean: The Second Story R receives mixed reviews, with praise for offering English and Japanese voice options, improved performances, and bringing characters to life with emotions. However, criticisms include humdrum line reads, subpar English voice acting, and inconsistencies in matching dialogue emotions. Overall, while having its strengths and weaknesses, the voice acting adds to the story's pace and character depth.

Critics rave about Star Ocean: The Second Story R's stellar technical performance on various platforms, especially on the PlayStation 5 with stable frame rates and resolutions. Minor issues like texture pop-in on the Nintendo Switch were noted but not game-breaking. Overall, the game delivers a smooth gaming experience across all platforms, ensuring players enjoy a technically solid performance no matter where they play.

Critics rave about Star Ocean: The Second Story R's replay value, praising its vast content, multiple endings, and customizable party members. The game's New Game Plus feature, high level of choice, and optional side stories enhance replayability. Minor drawbacks include the need for multiple playthroughs and party slot management. Overall, the game offers excellent replay value, with critics like Digital Chumps and RPG Site applauding its positive aspects.