Critics praise "The Story of Still Wakes the Deep" for its engaging narrative blending human aspects with Lovecraftian elements, delivering suspenseful storytelling with emotional depth. While some critics find shortcomings in depth and engagement, the majority appreciate its strong storytelling, rich environments, and character development. Despite some criticisms of unoriginality and underdone plot points, the game's immersive atmosphere and thematic depth make it a recommended narrative-driven adventure with horror elements.

Still Wakes the Deep gameplay: Critics praise immersive atmospheres, tension-building mechanics, and thrilling moments, but criticize repetitive tasks, lack of innovation, and missed opportunities for depth. Mixed reception with some enjoying the engaging experience while others find it uninspired. Appeals to players seeking straightforward immersion and tension, but may disappoint those craving complexity and innovation.

Critics rave about the stunning Graphics and Visual Design of Still Wakes the Deep, praising its detailed environments and photorealistic visuals. Some minor issues like smudgy graphics and performance hiccups were noted, but overall, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive. Advanced technologies like Nanite and ray tracing add to the game's visual appeal, creating an immersive and captivating experience for players.

Critics unanimously praised the sound design and music of Still Wakes the Deep for creating a chilling and immersive atmosphere with excellent voice acting and haunting sound effects. Some critiques included toned-down chase sequences and a lack of a strong scare factor, but overall, the game excels in its audio elements according to reviewers.

Critics praise the top-tier voice acting in Still Wakes the Deep for its authenticity, emotional depth, and immersive qualities, with Scottish accents adding realism. While some critics noted room for improvement in secondary character development, the majority agree that the performances bring the game to life and enhance the overall experience. Overall, the voice acting is a standout feature, drawing players into the game world with strong portrayals and compelling storytelling.

Still Wakes the Deep impresses on Xbox Series X with smooth gameplay, while facing technical woes on PS5. PC shines with minor hiccups. Overall, despite some flaws, the game offers a stable experience across platforms.

Critics praise Still Wakes the Deep for its engaging gameplay and intense horror experience, but point out its limited replay value due to linear progression, lack of player agency, and repetitive gameplay loop. Despite its strengths in narrative and atmosphere, the game's short length and lack of depth in gameplay mechanics may not offer enough incentives for multiple playthroughs according to reviewers.