Super Mario 3D All-Stars

Summary unavailable

The majority of critics praised the gameplay of Super Mario 3D All-Stars, highlighting various positive aspects across the three included titles. GameSkinny commended Super Mario 64 for its memorable levels and creative puzzles, while Player 2 appreciated the gameplay improvements in Super Mario Sunshine, such as enhanced controls and widescreen support. Additionally, KeenGamer noted the crisp and addictive gameplay, with each game offering a unique variation to Mario's abilities, providing a variety of missions, boss battles, and collect-a-thons. Critics like Nintendo Insider also lauded the groundbreaking achievement of Super Mario 64, the remarkable experience of Super Mario Galaxy, and the captivating level design of all three games. On the other hand, some critics pointed out certain negatives in the gameplay of Super Mario 3D All-Stars. App Trigger described the gameplay as subpar by today's standards, indicating a potential lack of modern gaming mechanics. We Got This Covered criticized issues with controls, camera, and the lack of improvements in the gameplay experience. Furthermore, Pocket Tactics mentioned the fussy camera and frustrating platforming sections in Super Mario 64 as drawbacks, while GamingBolt highlighted controversial controls and design choices in Super Mario Sunshine. Overall, the consensus among critics leans heavily towards a positive reception of the gameplay in Super Mario 3D All-Stars. The collection is praised for offering a mix of classic and innovative mechanics, providing a satisfying and engaging experience for players. Critics appreciated the nostalgic value, tight platforming, creative courses, and enjoyable movement present in the gameplay. Despite some criticisms regarding specific aspects like controls and camera issues in certain titles, the general sentiment is that the gameplay of Super Mario 3D All-Stars is enjoyable, offering a blend of familiar mechanics and new additions that showcase the evolution of Mario in 3D adventures. The positive reception from the majority of critics underscores the enduring appeal and quality of the gameplay experience in this collection.

The opinions of several critics highlight various positive aspects of the Graphics and Visual Design of Super Mario 3D All-Stars. Critics such as CGMagazine and Hobby Consolas praise the improved graphics in Super Mario Sunshine and the impressive design in Super Mario Galaxy. GameSpot and Noisy Pixel commend the upscaled HD quality visuals, with Noisy Pixel specifically mentioning it as the best way to experience Mario's 3D hits visually. Additionally, KeenGamer appreciates the high-definition resolutions and widescreen support in Super Mario Sunshine, enhancing the overall visual experience. On the other hand, criticisms regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Super Mario 3D All-Stars are also prevalent among reviewers. GamingTrend and GameSkinny note the lack of notable redesigns or significant visual enhancements, with GamingTrend specifically mentioning minimal resolution improvements. Forbes and App Trigger criticize the lack of modernization and updated visuals, with Forbes highlighting the issues in Super Mario 64 and Super Mario Sunshine. Furthermore, Worth Playing points out blurry-textured environments as a drawback in the visual presentation of the game. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Super Mario 3D All-Stars is mixed. While some critics appreciate the faithful recreations of the original games with improvements in resolution and visual quality, as mentioned by TheSixthAxis and Siliconera, others express disappointment in the lack of significant enhancements or modernization. Critics like VGC and Attack of the Fanboy acknowledge the varying levels of treatment each game received, with Super Mario Galaxy standing out for its visual improvements. Despite some criticisms, the game's nostalgic charm, improved resolutions, and timeless aesthetics seem to resonate positively with many reviewers, offering players an enhanced visual experience of these classic Mario titles.

The Sound Design and Music of Super Mario 3D All-Stars have received praise from multiple critics for the inclusion of full soundtracks from each game, enhancing the nostalgic experience for players. Critics like Atomix and Cubed3 have highlighted the standout feature of having separate access to each game's soundtrack, allowing players to enjoy the fantastic scores independently. The orchestrated soundtrack in Super Mario Galaxy, as noted by critics like Comicbook.com and Nintendojo, is particularly lauded for its amazing use of a full orchestra, adding to the overall enjoyment of the game. On the other hand, some critics have pointed out certain drawbacks regarding the Sound Design and Music of Super Mario 3D All-Stars. Critics like Digitally Downloaded and Noisy Pixel have mentioned that while the included soundtracks are lovely and serene, the lack of additional content or robust music player features may leave some players wanting more. Additionally, some critics, such as Shacknews, have criticized aspects like voice acting in Super Mario Sunshine for being cringe-inducing, highlighting areas where the sound design could have been improved. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the Sound Design and Music of Super Mario 3D All-Stars are a strong point of the collection, with the inclusion of full soundtracks being a major highlight. The ability to listen to iconic tunes from all three games, as praised by critics like GamingBolt and Pure Nintendo, adds to the overall charm and appeal of the package. While some critics have pointed out minor issues with the music player features or specific aspects of the sound design, the general sentiment is positive, with the music being a key factor in enhancing the gameplay experience for players across all three titles.

Summary unavailable

In terms of positives for the Nintendo Switch version of Super Mario 3D All-Stars, several critics highlighted the improved visuals and performance in Super Mario 64, with Atomix praising the upgraded visuals. GamesRadar+ also mentioned improved framerates and overall gameplay polish, while Gaming Age appreciated the well-done ports and spot-on emulation. Press Start Australia noted that Super Mario Galaxy runs smoothly at 60 FPS, and Siliconera mentioned the stable version of the games with some fixes and force feedback. On the flip side, some negatives were pointed out by critics for the Nintendo Switch version. Issues such as occasional frame rate drops in Super Mario Sunshine, camera angle problems, and control issues in Super Mario Galaxy were mentioned by various reviewers. Forbes criticized the lack of 60 FPS and 1080p resolution, while GamingTrend encountered a glitch in Super Mario 64 that required the game to be closed to fix. We Got This Covered highlighted technical issues like inconsistent frame rates and stuttering in Super Mario Sunshine, and ZTGD mentioned frame rate issues and control scheme problems in Super Mario 64 and Super Mario Sunshine. Overall, the consensus among the critics regarding the technical performance of Super Mario 3D All-Stars on the Nintendo Switch is mixed. While some reviewers appreciated the stable gameplay experience and improvements in visuals and controls, others pointed out issues like frame rate drops, control problems, and lack of optimization for modern displays. Comicbook.com and Pocket Tactics noted smooth performance and stable gameplay, while IGN Italia and KeenGamer highlighted technical issues and control drawbacks. Despite the mixed opinions, most critics agreed that the game runs smoothly and offers an enjoyable experience, with some technical hiccups affecting the overall performance on the Nintendo Switch platform.

The positive aspects of the Replay Value of Super Mario 3D All-Stars, as highlighted by several critics, include the extensive gameplay content and timeless nature of the games. Critics like Cubed3 and Digitally Downloaded praise the games for their excellent level design, innovative mechanics, and high playability, which contribute to infinite replayability and joy in revisiting the titles. Nintendo Life specifically mentions the substantial amount of content available, with a total of 482 Stars and Shines to collect across all three games, offering nearly 100 hours of gameplay before completion. The collection is also commended for providing a nostalgic and enjoyable experience for both new players and longtime fans, as noted by Atomix and Comicbook.com. On the other hand, the negative aspects of the Replay Value of Super Mario 3D All-Stars revolve around the lack of additional features, modernization, and updated controls, as pointed out by App Trigger. Critics like GameGrin and Hobby Consolas mention missed opportunities for enhancements and the absence of added content like galleries or development details, which could have enhanced the replay value for players. Additionally, some reviewers express disappointment in the lack of extras or significant updates, impacting the overall replay value for those looking for more content, as highlighted by GamingBolt and VGC. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the Replay Value of Super Mario 3D All-Stars leans towards the positive side, with many acknowledging the enduring appeal and enjoyable gameplay experiences offered by the classic Mario games. While there are concerns about the lack of additional content and missed opportunities for enhancements, the collection is still deemed worthwhile and a must-have for Switch owners, as noted by critics like Nintendojo and Worth Playing. The games' ability to captivate players, provide hours of gameplay, and offer a nostalgic trip back to some of Nintendo's greatest classics are key factors contributing to the overall positive reception of the collection's replay value.