Super Mario Maker 2

The Story Mode of Super Mario Maker 2 has received generally positive feedback from critics. Many reviewers appreciated the inclusion of a robust story mode with over 100 levels designed by Nintendo developers, serving as a great introduction to the game's building possibilities. Critics like Areajugones and GamePro Germany highlighted how the story mode provides a cohesive progression and serves as a tutorial for the level editor, offering helpful tutorials for beginners and showcasing the game's unique items and mechanics. Additionally, Press Start Australia praised the story mode for providing some of the best Mario platforming experiences and different difficulty levels to cater to a wide range of players. On the other hand, some critics found the story mode to be lacking in depth and substance. DarkStation criticized the comical tone of the story mode and mentioned that it fails to provide a satisfying experience due to its level design shortcomings. Similarly, Cultured Vultures noted that while the story mode is a bit lacking, it still offers some value with various levels created by Nintendo. Additionally, Multiplayer.it highlighted that the unique narrative premise of rebuilding Peach's castle falls short compared to traditional Super Mario Bros. adventures, suggesting a lack of innovation in the storytelling aspect. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the Story Mode of Super Mario Maker 2 is a welcome addition that provides an enjoyable experience for players. Critics like USgamer and Vandal appreciated the charming narrative framing and interactions with various characters, considering it a good tutorial for players on course design and philosophy. While there were criticisms regarding the depth and innovation of the story mode from some reviewers, the majority acknowledged its value in showcasing the game's creative potential and providing a solid foundation for players to explore and enjoy. The variety of levels, the progression system, and the overall charm of the narrative were highlighted as strengths of the story mode, making it a worthwhile component of the game according to the collective opinions of the critics.

The majority of critics praised the gameplay of Super Mario Maker 2, highlighting its robust level creation tools and diverse gameplay mechanics. Digitally Downloaded commended the game for providing a full toolset to create complex platforming levels, while Screen Rant appreciated the new features like vertical stages and Endless Challenge mode. Vandal specifically mentioned the improvements in the creation mode, such as the ability to create levels while the Switch is docked and the addition of clear conditions. Game Revolution noted that the game encourages thoughtful level design and creativity, offering extensive creation tools and themes from various Mario games. The addition of slopes, new elements, and clear conditions were highlighted as enhancing the gameplay experience by Vandal, Wccftech, and Game Rant. Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some critics did point out certain issues with Super Mario Maker 2's gameplay. Screen Rant mentioned that the online modes were plagued with issues like slowdown and lack of level selection, impacting the multiplayer experience. Impulsegamer noted that the creation tools were serviceable but inferior when using the controller instead of the touch screen, which could hinder the level designing process for some players. These criticisms suggest that while the core gameplay experience is highly praised, there are some technical and usability challenges that may affect certain aspects of the game. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the gameplay of Super Mario Maker 2. The game is lauded for its creativity-stimulating gameplay, intuitive level editor, and vast array of possibilities for level creation and playing. Critics like Gameplanet mentioned a bit of a learning curve at the start, but once mastered, the controls are cleverly thought out. The game's focus on creativity, experimentation, and providing a wide range of tools and elements for creative design resonated well with reviewers. Super Mario Maker 2's ability to inspire creativity, offer engaging gameplay mechanics, and provide hours of entertainment for players of all ages solidified its position as a standout title in the realm of user-generated content and level creation games.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Super Mario Maker 2 are overwhelmingly positive. Many critics praise the game for its vibrant and nostalgic visual design that captures the essence of classic Mario games while introducing new elements. Critics like My Nintendo News and GameSpot appreciate the improved user interface for level creation and the addition of new elements like the Cat Mario suit and the ability to make slopes, which enhance the overall visual appeal. Additionally, critics such as Game Revolution and Vandal commend the game for seamlessly integrating graphics from various Mario titles with new elements, creating a visually stunning experience. However, some critics express mixed opinions about certain aspects of the game's visual design. Critics like Multiplayer.it and Meristation criticize the polygonal graphics in Super Mario 3D World style, stating that it clashes with the rest of the game and lacks a fresh visual perspective. Game Informer also mentions that the 3D World theme doesn't mesh seamlessly with the other templates, leading to potential technical limitations. Despite these criticisms, other critics like Twinfinite and Impulsegamer appreciate the unique items and enemies introduced in the 3D World theme, highlighting its impressive visuals. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Super Mario Maker 2 offers a visually appealing and diverse experience for players. The game's rich and detailed visuals, along with the introduction of new themes like Night Mode and Super Mario 3D World style, are widely praised for enhancing the gameplay dynamics and providing players with a wide range of creative options. Critics like Universo Nintendo and Screen Rant commend the game for covering more than 30 years of Super Mario history with different visual styles and level themes, offering a nostalgic yet fresh visual experience. Despite some minor criticisms regarding certain visual elements, the majority of critics agree that Super Mario Maker 2 delivers a top-notch audio-visual experience with perfect controls and a user-friendly interface, making it a must-play for fans of the Mario franchise.

The opinions of multiple reviewers regarding the Sound Design and Music of Super Mario Maker 2 overwhelmingly praise the game for its exceptional audio experience. Critics like Atomix, FNintendo, and Nintendo Enthusiast highlight the inclusion of iconic Super Mario themes, classic Mario music, and sound effects that enhance the overall nostalgic and immersive experience of the game. The addition of new music and sound effects by Mario's iconic composer, Koji Kondo, as mentioned by Eurogamer Italy and The Sydney Morning Herald, is also lauded for bringing a magical and nostalgic touch to the gameplay. The variety of dynamic elements, such as different melodies for game environments and helpful sound effects for level creation, as noted by Merlin'in Kazanı and Nintenderos, further contribute to the positive reception of the sound design in Super Mario Maker 2. While the majority of critics express admiration for the sound design and music in Super Mario Maker 2, some minor criticisms are noted. NintendoWorldReport mentions missing some quirky touches from the original game, suggesting that there might be a slight lack of certain elements that fans of the series might have appreciated. Additionally, The Games Machine praises the unique sound effects but does not delve into further details, leaving room for interpretation that there might be areas where the sound design could have been further improved or expanded upon. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the Sound Design and Music of Super Mario Maker 2. The game is commended for its updated music, nostalgic sound design, variety of sounds and songs for level creation, and the inclusion of new music and sound effects that enhance the overall gameplay experience. The seamless integration of classic Mario elements with new additions, as highlighted by reviewers like Vandal and XGN, creates a delightful and immersive atmosphere that resonates with both longtime fans of the franchise and newcomers alike. The attention to detail in capturing the essence of a Mario game, as mentioned by Worth Playing, further solidifies Super Mario Maker 2 as a standout title in terms of its sound design and music, earning it high praise from the majority of critics.

Summary unavailable

In terms of the positives for Super Mario Maker 2 on the Nintendo Switch, several critics highlighted the smooth performance and stability of the game on the platform. Eurogamer Italy noted that the game runs smoothly with minimal heating issues, providing a stable experience. Additionally, Digitally Downloaded praised the game for being accessible and not too demanding on the technical skills of players, offering tutorials and guides for level design. Moreover, Everyeye.it mentioned the intuitive and efficient experience of creating levels using the touchscreen in handheld mode, showcasing the versatility of the Nintendo Switch. On the flip side, the negatives for the Nintendo Switch version of Super Mario Maker 2 mainly revolved around connectivity issues and lag affecting the multiplayer experience. Critics like BaziCenter and Nintendo Enthusiast pointed out connectivity issues and lag impacting online multiplayer, with Merlin'in Kazanı also noting occasional lag issues detracting from the overall stability of the game. Furthermore, Hobby Consolas highlighted drawbacks such as mandatory online accounts and slow matchmaking, while Pure Nintendo criticized significant post-launch shortcomings in the online implementation, making multiplayer borderline unplayable at times. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the technical performance of Super Mario Maker 2 on the Nintendo Switch leans towards a mixed reception. While some critics appreciated the stable performance and intuitive controls in handheld mode, others were critical of the connectivity issues, lag in multiplayer modes, and limitations in online capabilities. JeuxActu and Pure Nintendo's critiques of unstable online multiplayer experiences and significant post-launch shortcomings reflect a need for improvements in network stability and online implementation. However, with updates expected to address these issues, there is potential for the game to enhance its technical performance and provide a more seamless multiplayer experience on the Nintendo Switch.

The majority of critics praised the replay value of Super Mario Maker 2, highlighting its vast array of user-generated content, online features, and creative potential. Critics like DualShockers, COGconnected, and Game Rant commended the game for offering endless opportunities for players to create and play custom levels, with DualShockers specifically mentioning the addition of a formal campaign enhancing the replayability. The inclusion of features like Course World, Endless Challenge mode, and multiplayer options, as noted by Eurogamer Italy and Press Start Australia, further contribute to the game's high replay value. The ability to engage with a vibrant community, explore uncharted levels, and leave comments for creators, as mentioned by GamingTrend and Vandal, adds depth to the replay experience. On the downside, some critics pointed out certain limitations that could impact the replay value of Super Mario Maker 2. Softpedia highlighted that playing one's own levels may not be as rewarding since players already know them, potentially reducing the incentive for replay. Screen Rant mentioned issues with online modes that could affect long-term replayability, while Game Informer expressed disappointment at only being able to play online with random players at launch. Additionally, Digitally Downloaded mentioned a limit of 32 courses that can be uploaded, which could restrict the variety of content available for replay. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the replay value of Super Mario Maker 2. The game's emphasis on user-generated content, diverse gameplay options, and engaging community features has been widely praised, with critics noting its near limitless replay potential. Despite some minor drawbacks such as limited level uploads and online mode issues, the majority of reviewers agree that Super Mario Maker 2 offers a wealth of content and creative possibilities that ensure players will find endless enjoyment and replay value in the game. The game's ability to cater to both casual and hardcore gamers, as highlighted by Eurogamer Italy, and its continuous stream of new levels from the community, as noted by Metro GameCentral, further solidify its reputation as a title with exceptional replayability.