Ys IX: Monstrum Nox

The opinions of the critics regarding the Story of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox are quite diverse, with both positive and negative aspects highlighted. Several critics, such as RPGamer, Pure Nintendo, and RPG Site, praise the story for its well-crafted narrative, engaging character interactions, and surprising twists. They appreciate the nods to the franchise's history and the satisfying resolution of early surprises. The Mako Reactor also commends the game for building upon the foundation laid by its predecessor, Ys VIII, to deliver a better gameplay and story experience. These positive opinions indicate that the story successfully captures the attention of players and provides a compelling and enjoyable narrative. On the other hand, some critics express negative sentiments towards the story of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox. Gaming Age criticizes the game for its long-winded explanations and cutscenes that hinder the action, while Push Square mentions that the focus on individual character development leads to a fragmented and contrived overarching plot. ZTGD finds the big story reveals to be predictable and the segments where the player is a prisoner to be boring. These criticisms suggest that the story may suffer from pacing issues, excessive exposition, and a lack of cohesion in its narrative structure. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the story of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox is engaging, with a darker tone and intriguing plot twists. Critics like TheSixthAxis, Hey Poor Player, and DualShockers appreciate the heavier focus on storytelling and the development of the main characters. However, some critics, such as GamingBolt and Push Square, believe that the story falls short in certain aspects, such as its execution and overarching plot. Despite these criticisms, the majority of reviewers find the story to be enjoyable and well-crafted, with memorable characters and satisfying character growth and reveals. The positive opinions outweigh the negative ones, indicating that the overall sentiment towards the story of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox is favorable.

Analysis: The majority of the critics praised the gameplay of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox, considering it to be very good. The combat system was a standout feature, with many reviewers highlighting its fast-paced and enjoyable nature. The real-time battles, character swapping, and various skills and abilities were mentioned as contributing to the overall enjoyment of the gameplay experience (RPG Site, Easy Allies, Impulsegamer). The addition of Monstrum abilities and unique traversal abilities for each character added depth and strategy to the combat and exploration aspects of the game (Finger Guns, Hey Poor Player, Universo Nintendo). The combat was described as addictive, satisfying, and offering a blast to play through (Impulsegamer, COGconnected, Cubed3). The inclusion of special attacks, combo attacks, and skill attacks further enhanced the combat mechanics (Easy Allies, The Indie Game Website, GamingBolt). However, there were some criticisms regarding the gameplay of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox. Some critics mentioned that the combat mechanics were not revolutionary and followed the typical hack and slash mechanics of the series (Video Chums). The traversal abilities, while adding verticality to the game, were not fully utilized in the game world, leading to a feeling of limitation (Finger Guns). The game was also criticized for its limited number of locations to explore compared to previous games (SpazioGames). The excessive cut-scenes and bombastic storytelling were seen as drawbacks by some critics (Cubed3). The camera positioning was mentioned as an issue, affecting the intensity of the battles (Jeuxvideo.com). Overall, the consensus among the critics was that the gameplay of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox was highly enjoyable and addictive. The combat mechanics, character abilities, and exploration elements were praised for their depth and engagement (RPG Fan, Nintendo Life, GameSpew). The fast-paced and action-packed nature of the combat was highlighted as a positive aspect (God is a Geek, DualShockers). The addition of new gameplay elements, such as Monstrum abilities and traversal abilities, was seen as a welcome evolution of the franchise (Hey Poor Player, Wccftech). While there were some criticisms regarding the lack of innovation in the combat mechanics and limited utilization of certain gameplay features, the overall sentiment was positive, with the majority of critics considering the gameplay of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox to be a strong aspect of the game.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox are quite varied. Some critics, such as Hardcore Gamer and Digitally Downloaded, praise the game's visuals, highlighting the detailed character designs and clean 3D models. They appreciate the distinct art direction and the grand architectural design of the city of Balduq. The environments are described as well-done and expertly designed, with hidden collectibles and movement options, as noted by BaziCenter and Noisy Pixel. These positive aspects contribute to the overall appeal of the game's graphics. However, there are several negative opinions regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox. Critics like Pure Nintendo, Vandal, and Universo Nintendo criticize the game for lacking detail in background textures and character movements that feel odd in the environment. Performance issues, including framerate drops and low frames per second, are particularly noticeable during intense battles and in docked mode, as mentioned by Pure Nintendo. The graphics are also criticized for being blurry, low-resolution, and suffering from noticeable pop-in and performance issues, according to Vandal. Universo Nintendo specifically points out the poor visuals, lack of lighting and shadows, especially in the Switch version. Other critics, such as Everyeye.it and ZTGD, mention pixelated graphics, jagged edges on character models, and a lack of variety in locations, with the overwhelming grey color-scape becoming dull. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the Graphics and Visual Design of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox have both positive and negative aspects. While some critics appreciate the detailed character designs, distinct art direction, and well-designed environments, others criticize the lack of detail, performance issues, and the overall outdated feel of the graphics. The game's visuals are described as a mixed bag, with improvements from previous entries but still feeling outdated compared to current generation games, as noted by Finger Guns. The graphics are considered to be a step above its predecessor by GameSkinny, with vibrant colors and detailed character models, but the lack of environmental variety makes certain areas feel repetitive, according to Video Chums. The overall consensus leans towards the negative side, with criticisms of outdated technology, graphical limitations, and a lack of visual variety. However, it is worth noting that some critics still find enjoyment in the combat visuals, character designs, and specific aspects of the game's visual aesthetics.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox are generally positive. Many critics praise the sound design, including the music and voice acting, for enhancing the immersive experience of the game. Critics like Areajugones and Easy Allies appreciate the satisfying sound design that brings the characters to life through well-executed voice acting and a well-crafted soundtrack. BaziCenter and GameSpew highlight the suitability of the music design to both action-packed moments and serene moments, adding to the thrill and pleasure of the gameplay. The music is described as solid, great, top-notch, and enjoyable by DualShockers, GameSpew, PlayStation Country, and Nintenderos, respectively. The soundtrack is also praised for its impact and atmosphere, as mentioned by GameSkinny and Noisy Pixel. The music is considered a standout aspect, with thrilling pieces and clever remixes of past themes, as noted by RPG Site. The high-octane music during defense mode is mentioned by GamingTrend to create an arcade-like experience. The classical inspiration and memorable tracks of the soundtrack are appreciated by Hobby Consolas and Vandal, respectively. However, there are some critics who express disappointment with the music in Ys IX: Monstrum Nox. DarkStation, Finger Guns, RPG Fan, and Hey Poor Player find the soundtrack to be good but not particularly memorable or as inspiring as previous titles in the series. Meristation and SpazioGames also note that the music doesn't reach the level of previous entries in the series. RPGamer mentions that the music is a letdown compared to earlier Ys titles, although it still describes the soundtrack as killer and upbeat. Wccftech mentions that the soundtrack is hit-and-miss, with some standout pieces but also some generic tracks. Despite these negative opinions, the overall sentiment towards the sound design and music remains positive. In conclusion, the majority of critics have a positive view of the sound design and music in Ys IX: Monstrum Nox. The immersive and satisfying sound design, including the voice acting and music, enhances the gameplay experience according to critics like Areajugones and Easy Allies. The soundtrack is praised for its suitability to different moments and locations, with standout tracks and a wide selection of styles. However, there are some critics who express disappointment with the music, finding it not as memorable or inspiring as previous entries in the series. Despite these mixed opinions, the overall consensus is that the sound design and music contribute positively to the game, with the majority of critics appreciating the quality and impact of the soundtrack.

The overall sentiment regarding the voice acting in Ys IX: Monstrum Nox is largely positive, with several critics praising the performances and immersion it brings to the game. Critics such as Areajugones and GamingBolt highlight the impressive voice acting, with the latter mentioning how it properly heightens emotional moments and brings life to the dialogue. Easy Allies and Noisy Pixel also commend the voice work, with the former mentioning how it brings each character to life and the latter describing it as fitting and consistently believable. However, there are some criticisms regarding the voice acting in Ys IX: Monstrum Nox. The Mako Reactor points out that while the English voice acting is enjoyable, there is a lack of voice acting in some parts of the game, possibly due to budgetary constraints. RPGamer also mentions the lack of voice acting in certain areas, which may be a drawback for some players. PLAY! Zine highlights the absence of the main character's voice, which is seen as a significant drawback considering his presence in previous games. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the voice acting in Ys IX: Monstrum Nox is well done and adds to the immersion of the game. Critics such as Everyeye.it and SpazioGames praise both the English and Japanese voice acting, with no issues found in the English localization. Video Chums and Wccftech describe the voice acting as great and mostly adequate, respectively. However, there are some mixed opinions, with critics like RPG Fan and Hey Poor Player finding the voice acting to be adequate but not particularly memorable. Despite some minor criticisms, the majority of critics agree that the voice acting in Ys IX: Monstrum Nox is a positive aspect of the game.

In terms of the technical performance on the PS4, the opinions of the critics are mixed. Some reviewers, such as DarkStation and Easy Allies, mention that the game runs smoothly without any major issues. They highlight stable frame rates, fast loading times, and a lack of frustrating hiccups or bugs. However, other critics like Areajugones and DualShockers criticize the game for its subpar technical aspects. They mention issues such as crashes, frame rate drops, and outdated graphics. Eurogamer Italy specifically points out that the game struggles on previous generation consoles like the PS4 Pro, particularly during city exploration where the frame rate drops below 15fps. Overall, the PS4 version of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox seems to have a mix of positive and negative technical performance aspects. Moving on to the PS5 version, the opinions of the critics are generally more positive. GamersRD, Hey Poor Player, and The Mako Reactor highlight the stable 60fps frame rate, shorter loading times, and smoother performance on the PS5. They mention that the enhanced version improves framerate consistency, load times, and overall stability compared to the PS4 version. However, some critics, like IGN Italia and WellPlayed, criticize the graphics for feeling dated on the PS5. Despite these minor criticisms, the overall consensus is that the PS5 version offers a better technical performance compared to the PS4 version. When it comes to the Nintendo Switch version, the critics are mostly critical of its technical performance. Multiple reviewers, including Nintendo Life, NintendoWorldReport, and Pure Nintendo, mention significant frame rate drops, inconsistent performance, and muddy visuals. They highlight issues with the frame rate in open areas, crowded areas, and during combat encounters. The text size is also mentioned as being too small to comfortably read in handheld mode. While some reviewers mention that the game generally runs well on the Switch, the majority of opinions lean towards the negative side, with the Switch version being described as the weakest in terms of performance. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Ys IX: Monstrum Nox has mixed technical performance across different gaming platforms. While some platforms, like the PS5, offer a smoother and more stable experience, others, like the Nintendo Switch, suffer from significant frame rate drops and performance issues. The PS4 version falls somewhere in between, with a mix of positive and negative aspects. It's worth noting that some critics, like RPGamer and COGconnected, mention that certain technical issues were resolved with patches, indicating that the developers are actively working to improve the game's performance.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of Ys IX: Monstrum Nox are generally positive. Many critics highlight the various gameplay elements that contribute to the game's replayability. For example, BaziCenter mentions the variety of combat styles and weapons, which enhance the sense of progression and excitement. Eurogamer Italy praises the extra game modes such as New Game +, Time Attack, and Boss Rush, which provide good replayability. GameOver.gr also mentions the new game plus feature and trophies obtained through exploration, providing hours of engaging gameplay. Additionally, Multiplayer.it highlights the variety of trophies to unlock, which can be obtained through different gameplay aspects. These positive aspects contribute to the overall replay value of the game. However, there are some negative aspects mentioned by the critics. Meristation points out that the gameplay can become repetitive over time, which may affect the long-term replayability of the game. Metro GameCentral mentions that the game, while enjoyable and breezy, may not be as good as its predecessor and can be completed in 30 hours. Hey Poor Player also notes that the repetitive encounters in the Grimwald Nox may limit long-term replayability. These negative aspects should be considered when evaluating the overall replay value of the game. Overall, the critics' opinions suggest that Ys IX: Monstrum Nox has good replay value. The game offers a variety of gameplay elements such as combat styles, game modes, trophies, and post-game content, which contribute to its replayability. Critics like Easy Allies describe it as "RPG comfort food" that invites players to explore the world and enjoy the game without feeling pressured to replay it. The positive aspects mentioned by the critics outweigh the negative aspects, indicating that the game provides a satisfying replay value for both experienced players and newcomers to the genre. However, it is important to note that some critics mention repetitive gameplay and shorter playtime compared to its predecessor, which may affect the overall replayability for certain players.