Critics are divided on the story of Alone in the Dark. Some praise its unique character perspectives, Lovecraftian elements, and engaging narrative centered on puzzles. Others criticize its underwhelming execution, lack of fleshed-out characters, and uninteresting dialogue. Overall, the game's strengths lie in its thematic elements and character dynamics, while weaknesses include inconsistencies in execution and narrative delivery.

Alone in the Dark gameplay received mixed reviews: praised for well-designed puzzles and strategic elements, but criticized for clunky movement, uninspired combat, and repetitive puzzles. While some lauded its survival horror approach, others found issues like dated mechanics and lackluster gunplay. Overall, the game excels in horror and atmosphere but falls short in gameplay execution, leading to a divisive reception among critics.

Alone in the Dark's visuals divide critics: praised for its richly crafted gothic atmosphere and unique settings like Derceto Manor, but criticized for technical issues like crashes and generic textures. Despite flaws, the game offers an immersive horror experience with eerie scares and impressive level design, though lacking originality. Critics appreciate the effort but suggest improvements for future iterations.

The sound design and music of Alone in the Dark sparked mixed reviews. Critics praised the jazz-infused soundtrack and immersive sound design for adding personality and enhancing the eerie atmosphere. Positive notes included the strong voice acting and malevolent noises that heightened the survival horror experience. However, criticisms were directed at issues like lackluster gunplay, disinterested voice performances, and late audio cues, which detracted from the overall enjoyment. Overall, opinions were divided, with some aspects shining while others fell short, leading to a polarizing reception among players.

Critics have mixed opinions on the voice acting in Alone in the Dark. Some praised the strong performances of A-list actors like Jodie Comer and David Harbour, enhancing immersion and character development. Others criticized inconsistencies and lack of depth in supporting cast performances, impacting the overall gameplay experience. Renowned actors added quality, but varying execution led to divided opinions on the effectiveness of the voice acting.

Alone in the Dark faces widespread technical issues across gaming platforms, from audio glitches to game-breaking bugs. Critics point out severe problems like crashes, unreliable button prompts, and combat mechanics issues. Despite some positive notes, the consensus is that the game falls short of a polished experience, with bugs and performance issues hampering gameplay enjoyment.

Critics are divided on the Replay Value of Alone in the Dark. Some praise its unique sequences and collectibles that unlock forbidden knowledge, making multiple playthroughs enticing. However, others criticize the lack of significant story differences and uninspired gameplay, which may deter replaying. Overall, the game offers potential for replay value through exploring secrets and unique cutscenes, but concerns exist about gameplay depth and originality.