Days Gone's story receives mixed reviews: praised for emotional depth, character development, and engaging relationships by some, but criticized for cliches, lack of depth, and pacing issues by others. The narrative explores themes of grief and relationships, but struggles with predictability and generic side missions. Critics agree on a captivating post-apocalyptic world and relatable protagonist, but debate over the execution of the story, calling for a more concise and focused approach.

Days Gone gameplay praised for satisfying combat and engaging horde encounters, but criticized for repetitive missions and lackluster enemy AI. Mixed opinions on unique elements like zombie hordes and survival mechanics. Offers dynamic experience with thrilling moments and some frustrations, as noted by critics.

Days Gone receives high praise for its stunning visuals, detailed environments, and atmospheric world design from critics, with accolades for its beautiful landscapes, dynamic weather, and realistic character models. However, technical issues such as rendering problems, crashes, framerate drops, and texture loading problems detract from the overall visual experience, according to critics. While the game showcases impressive graphics, there is a consensus among reviewers that improvements are needed to optimize technical aspects for a smoother and more immersive presentation.

Critics praised Days Gone for its exceptional sound design and music, creating immersive gameplay experiences with quality sound effects. Some highlighted the satisfaction of gun sounds and tense atmosphere enhanced by weather conditions. However, issues like inconsistent sound levels, immersion-breaking moments, and technical glitches were noted. Overall, critics leaned towards the positive, appreciating the immersive atmosphere, voice acting quality, and music impact despite some drawbacks.

Critics have mixed opinions on the voice acting in Days Gone. While some praise Sam Witwer's performance as Deacon St. John for its depth and emotion, others criticize inconsistencies and lack of depth in characterizations. Overall, the voice acting adds to the game's immersion and storytelling, but some performances fell short, according to various critics.

Critics praise Days Gone on PC for stable performance and high frame rates, while PS4 version faces issues like poor optimization and frequent bugs. PC offers smoother gameplay experience, outperforming PS4 in technical performance.

Critics have mixed opinions on the replay value of Days Gone. Some praise its dense content, evolving protagonist, and engaging combat for completionists, while others criticize its lack of innovation, repetitive missions, and lack of depth. Overall, the consensus is that while the game offers some replayability with its variety of activities, upgrades, and choices, concerns about repetitive gameplay and lack of depth may limit long-term engagement for multiple playthroughs.