Critics have mixed opinions on the story of For Honor. Some praise its context-building for factions and characters, while others criticize it for being confusing and shallow. Overall, the consensus is that while the story has strengths, it lacks depth and fails to engage players beyond serving as a tutorial for multiplayer.

Critics rave about For Honor's deep and engaging combat system, praising its strategic depth and skill-based gameplay. However, issues with connectivity, matchmaking, and microtransactions drew criticism. Overall, For Honor's gameplay shines with its nuanced combat mechanics and diverse character classes, offering a fresh take on the fighting game genre, despite some technical hiccups.

For Honor's graphics and visual design received high praise from critics for stunning visuals, detailed character models, and immersive environments. Some critics noted issues like emptiness in the world and challenges in character distinctions during gameplay. Overall, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with the game being lauded as one of the best-looking in the industry, offering an engaging medieval fantasy experience with gritty combat and striking graphics.

Critics have mixed opinions on the Sound Design and Music of For Honor. Positive feedback highlights high-quality voice acting, immersive sound design, and impactful combat sounds. However, some critics criticize authenticity issues and technical problems, such as desynching and crashes. Despite the negatives, most critics agree that the immersive audio elements enhance the gameplay experience, creating a positive overall reception.

Critics had mixed feelings about the voice acting in For Honor. Some praised the strong performances and recognizable talent, while others criticized the dialogue as cliched and the accents inconsistent. Overall, opinions varied on whether the voice acting enhanced or detracted from the immersive experience of the game.

For Honor runs smoothly on PS4 with improved online performance, but faces server stability issues. PC version has smooth gameplay but suffers from Peer-to-Peer connectivity problems and lack of dedicated servers. Xbox One version also experiences connectivity issues. Overall, technical performance challenges persist across all platforms, calling for ongoing optimization to enhance the gaming experience.

Critics have mixed opinions on the replay value of For Honor. Positive aspects include engaging multiplayer modes, customization options, and a well-balanced competitive experience. However, criticisms focus on unreliable online experiences, poor matchmaking, and pay-to-win elements. Despite these drawbacks, the game's diverse fighters, multiplayer modes, and ongoing support contribute to its replay value, though issues like matchmaking problems and microtransactions may impact its long-term appeal.