Critics have mixed opinions on Attack on Titan 2. Positive points include the addition of a player-created character, iconic scenes from the manga and anime, and capturing the source material's gravitas. However, some criticize the repetitive story beats, lack of coherence, and slow pacing. Overall, the game offers a varied story experience with strong characters but some narrative drawbacks.

Critics overwhelmingly praise Attack on Titan 2 gameplay for its fast-paced combat, fluid movement, and strategic Titan-killing mechanics. The addition of new features like online modes enhances the overall experience. While some critics found the gameplay mechanics repetitive and cited issues with AI and camera angles, the majority agree that it is highly enjoyable and satisfying.

Critics praise Attack on Titan 2 for its stunning visuals, distinctive appearance, and well-animated cutscenes that capture the essence of the source material. However, some mention issues like reused assets and visual pop-ins, preventing it from reaching its full potential. Overall, the game brings the manga and anime characters to life but falls short of being cutting edge in graphics.

Critics praise Attack on Titan 2's sound design and music, highlighting authentic voice acting and grandiose music from the original Japanese cast. Positive feedback includes the immersive sound effects and non-irritating battle chatter. However, critics note the absence of an English dub and music from Hiroyuki Sawano. Despite some drawbacks, the consensus is that the game's audio elements enhance the overall experience.

Critics mostly praise Attack on Titan 2's voice acting, especially the Japanese cast, for bringing characters to life with emotion and intensity. While some mention flaws like gender inconsistencies and lack of voice lines for the player's character, the overall consensus is that the high-quality performances enhance the game's experience.

Attack on Titan 2 impresses critics with strong technical performance on Xbox One X and PC, offering high frame rates and smooth gameplay. However, issues like buggy Titan movements and occasional slowdowns on PS4 and Switch versions dampen the experience. Despite minor flaws, the game delivers an overall satisfying performance on all platforms.

Critics are divided on the replay value of Attack on Titan 2. Some praise its additional modes, online features, and addictive gameplay, while others criticize its repetitive mechanics and lackluster visuals. Overall, the game offers plenty of content and challenges, but potential drawbacks like grind and limited variety may impact its long-term appeal.