Critics have mixed opinions on Astral Chain's story. Some praise its unique concept, captivating storytelling, and character development, while others criticize it for being predictable and lacking depth. The game's narrative engages players with its world but may not offer enough originality or complexity for all. Overall, Astral Chain's storytelling has moments of greatness but also suffers from shortcomings like cliches and tonal shifts. Despite these flaws, its enjoyable gameplay and captivating world make up for them according to many critics.

Critics rave about Astral Chain's gameplay, praising its fast-paced combat mechanics with special X-Baton weapons and summonable Legions. The combat is described as fantastic, engaging, and reminiscent of Platinum Games titles like Bayonetta. While some critics mention issues with movement precision and controls, the overall consensus is highly positive. The game's incorporation of investigation, exploration, and side quests adds depth and variety, making it a must-play for fans of innovative gameplay experiences.

Astral Chain wows critics with stunning graphics and visual design, praised for cel-shaded art, unique character designs, and neon-lit metropolis setting. Some minor criticisms noted, but overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive.

Critics unanimously praise Astral Chain's sound design and music, hailing the soundtrack as stellar and diverse. With electric, metal, orchestral, and vocal tracks seamlessly fitting the game's mood, critics like Attack of the Fanboy and GameGrin commend the high-energy synth soundtrack for bringing the neon world to life. Notably, there were no negative criticisms, and the majority agree that the exceptional sound design and music elevate the overall experience, making it one of the best of the year.

Critics have mixed opinions on the voice acting in Astral Chain. Positive reviews from COGconnected, Nintendo Enthusiast, and TheSixthAxis praise the high-quality acting that enhances the game. However, GameSpot and Slant Magazine criticize the silent protagonist and dialogue imbalance. Overall, while there are some flaws, the consensus leans towards a generally positive reception of the voice acting in Astral Chain.

Critics mostly praise Astral Chain's technical performance on the Nintendo Switch, highlighting smooth running in both handheld and docked modes, tight controls, and mesmerizing combat sequences. Some minor technical hiccups like occasional framerate dips and camera issues were mentioned, but overall, the game effectively utilizes the Switch's features and impresses with its performance.

Critics praise Astral Chain for its high replay value due to diverse gameplay elements like multiple difficulties, side missions, item collecting, and character customization. RPG aspects, upgrade systems, New Game+ options, and postgame content further enhance replayability. Some criticisms include difficulty in locating objective markers. Overall, critics agree that Astral Chain offers a compelling experience that encourages replaying.