Critics have mixed opinions on Horizon Forbidden West's story. Positive reviews praise the engaging narrative, character development, and surprises. However, negative feedback criticizes the lack of compelling conflict and underdeveloped characters. Overall, while some find faults like rushed parts and dull characters, most appreciate the engaging storytelling, character development, and world-building that captivate players.

Critics rave about Horizon Forbidden West's gameplay, praising its improved combat mechanics, diverse activities, and engaging battles against mechanical creatures. While some critics found aspects repetitive or lacking innovation, the majority lauded the game for its fun and satisfying gameplay experiences. Overall, Horizon Forbidden West's gameplay receives high praise for its adrenaline-pumping battles and wide range of options, despite minor criticisms of similarities to other games and some gameplay elements.

Critics rave about Horizon Forbidden West's stunning graphics and visual design, praising its high-quality visuals, attention to detail, vibrant colors, and diverse environments. While some critics had minor criticisms like uneven cutscene quality and occasional technical issues, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with the majority impressed by the game's next-gen visuals and immersive world.

Critics laud Horizon Forbidden West's sound design and music, praising the excellent soundtrack, voice acting, and immersive ambient sounds that heighten the gameplay experience. While some raise concerns about the protagonist's voice, overall consensus is positive, with the majority highlighting the game's impressive soundscapes, diverse cast of voiced characters, and innovative use of the DualSense controller's features.

Critics largely praise voice acting in Horizon Forbidden West as fantastic, engaging, and well-acted, with standout performances from main characters like Aloy and Zo. Some minor issues noted include struggling with accents and occasional forced dialogue, but overall, the voice acting adds to the immersive experience of the game.

Critics lauded Horizon Forbidden West on PS5 for its smooth animations, quick loading, and consistent frame rate. Some minor technical issues were noted, like texture problems and bugs, especially on PS4. Overall, the game's technical performance on PS5 impressed reviewers, while the PS4 version had more noticeable glitches and lags.

Critics widely praise Horizon Forbidden West for its high replay value, citing its vast world, abundance of content, and engaging gameplay. While some critics mention minor drawbacks like lack of significant gameplay changes and tedious side quests, the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive. The game's rich lore, numerous quests, and constant rewards contribute to a fulfilling and immersive experience, making it a highly recommended choice for players seeking exploration and replayability.