Critics have mixed feelings about Darksiders III's story. Some praise its engaging dialogue, character development, and narrative twists, while others criticize it for lacking depth, originality, and character exploration. The focus on Fury's quest to track down the Seven Deadly Sins was engaging for some but fell short for others due to predictability and lack of meaningful progression. Overall, opinions vary on the story's impact and depth, resulting in a divided reception among reviewers.

Critics praise Darksiders III for its satisfying combat mechanics, requiring strategy and timing. However, some criticize it for lacking depth, being repetitive, and having technical issues. Overall, opinions are divided on the combat inspired by Dark Souls, with some enjoying the challenge while others find it mechanical. The game's focus on combat over puzzles also receives mixed feedback.

Critics have mixed feelings about Darksiders III graphics. Some praise the diverse character designs and stunning boss arenas, while others criticize the outdated visuals, lack of variety, and technical issues. Overall, the consensus is that the game falls short in the graphics department, with concerns about visual variety and performance problems overshadowing its positive aspects.

Critics praised Darksiders III for its top-notch voice acting but criticized technical issues like audio bugs and stuttering. While some appreciated the immersive world created by the English voice acting and soundtrack, others found the audio experience lacking in immersion and memorable music. Overall, the game's sound design and music received a mixed reception among critics, with the quality of voice acting standing out despite the technical drawbacks.

Critics had mixed opinions on the voice acting in Darksiders III. Positive feedback praised Cissy Jones for her portrayal of Fury, citing depth and charisma, while some criticized the voice acting as forgettable and lacking emotional depth. Overall, opinions were divided, with Jones' performance standing out positively, but some noting weaknesses like cheesiness and underwhelming performances.

Darksiders III received praise for stable performance on PS4 and immersive gameplay on Xbox One X, but all platforms faced major technical issues like frame rate drops and bugs. Critics agree that these issues hindered gameplay enjoyment across the board, overshadowing any positive aspects of the game.

Darksiders III's replay value divides critics: praised for diverse gameplay and customization options, but criticized for technical issues and lack of depth. While some find the combat satisfying and addictive, others feel the linear progression and repetitive gameplay limit replayability. Overall, mixed opinions on whether the game offers enough to warrant multiple playthroughs.