Critics rave about Marvel's Spider-Man 2 story, praising its development, emotional depth, and engaging plot. They appreciate the mentorship dynamic between Peter Parker and Miles Morales, as well as the chemistry between voice actors Yuri Lowenthal and Nadji Jeter. The appearance of various villains is well-executed and tonally consistent. While some reviewers note criticisms like lack of emotional depth and repetitive themes, the overall consensus is that the story is highly enjoyable, well-crafted, and a standout aspect of the game.

Critics rave about Marvel's Spider-Man 2 gameplay, praising its polished combat mechanics, new abilities, and exciting combos. The addition of diverse powers for both Spider-Men, enhanced traversal abilities, and new playable characters elevate the gaming experience. While some critics find quick-time events and side missions lacking, overall, the gameplay is tight, engaging, and satisfying, with minimal flaws. The consensus is that Marvel's Spider-Man 2 delivers an enjoyable, improved gaming experience that surpasses its predecessors.

Critics unanimously praise Marvel's Spider-Man 2 for its stunning graphics and visual design, highlighting the immersive depiction of New York City with minute detail and impressive character models. While some minor criticisms were noted, the overall consensus is that the game's visuals are exceptional and among the best of the modern era, enhancing the overall Spider-Man experience.

Critics rave about Marvel's Spider-Man 2's top-notch sound design and music, praising its immersive qualities and use of DualSense features. The soundtrack is lauded for its heroic themes and emotional impact, with no major criticisms noted. Overall, the consensus is that the game's audio enhances the cinematic experience, with exceptional sound effects and music that elevate gameplay to Hollywood-level production value.

Critics rave about the exceptional voice acting in Marvel's Spider-Man 2, praising the actors' ability to bring characters to life and add emotional depth to the narrative. Standout performances by Yuri Lowenthal and Nadji Jeter as Peter Parker and Miles Morales were highlighted, with only minor criticisms about the writing mentioned. Overall, the voice acting received widespread acclaim for its top-notch quality and engaging delivery.

Critics raved about Marvel's Spider-Man 2 on the PS5, praising its use of the console's features like fast loading times and DualSense controller support. Insomniac Games' attention to detail impressed, with a consistent 60FPS framerate and minimal bugs. While some minor issues were noted, the game was hailed as a technical marvel, showcasing the PS5's capabilities and delivering a seamless and immersive gaming experience.

Marvel's Spider-Man 2 offers a mix of opinions on replay value. Critics praise the game for its side missions, activities, and collectibles that enhance replayability, with some noting up to 30-40 hours for completion. The open world of New York is packed with distractions and exploration opportunities. However, criticisms include repetitive side missions, lack of variety in the open world, and uninteresting random crimes. Overall, critics agree that the game provides significant additional content and challenges, making it worth replaying for fans of the Spider-Man franchise.