Watch Dogs: Legion's story impressed some critics for its bold political themes and gritty narrative tackling societal issues like crime and fascism. Critics praised the writing and missions for creating a socially complex world, but others criticized the lack of a central protagonist and emotional depth, feeling that player-created characters overshadowed the plot. Overall, opinions on the story are mixed, with some enjoying the thematic exploration while others found it lacking in emotional impact and depth.

Watch Dogs: Legion impresses with its 'Play As Anyone' feature, allowing diverse character recruitment for strategic gameplay, as praised by critics. However, repetitive missions, lackluster combat, and character development issues are noted drawbacks. While innovative ideas add depth, execution falls short in mission variety and engagement. Players seeking strategic options may enjoy it, but those wanting more refined gameplay might be disappointed.

Critics raved about Watch Dogs: Legion's impressive graphics, with praise for the stunning London environment on PS5 and real-time ray-tracing on PC. While some noted flaws like stiff animations and lack of character detail, the majority praised the faithful recreation of London's landmarks and immersive atmosphere, making it a visually appealing and immersive experience overall.

Watch Dogs: Legion received praise for its authentic portrayal of London through sound design and music, capturing British culture with detailed accents and iconic landmarks. Critics loved the exciting soundtrack but criticized voice acting inconsistencies and repetitive dialogue, with some finding it immersion-breaking. Overall, opinions on the game's audio were mixed, with some appreciating its authenticity while others pointed out flaws like repetitive voice acting and poor dialogue.

Critics had mixed feelings about the voice acting in Watch Dogs: Legion. Positive aspects included diverse character voices and the AI assistant, Bagley. However, negative reviews criticized the voice acting for being sketchy, repetitive, and inconsistent, with some calling it poor and lacking depth. Overall, the consensus leans towards the negative side, with issues like wooden delivery, mismatched voices and visuals, and lack of compelling characters overshadowing the positives.

Critics praised PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X for improved loading times and smoother gameplay in Watch Dogs: Legion, but pointed out issues like bugs, crashes, and stability problems on PS4, Xbox One, and PC. Overall, technical performance was a mixed bag across platforms, with some positives overshadowed by significant drawbacks and the need for patches to enhance stability.

Critics are divided on the replay value of Watch Dogs: Legion. Some praise its diverse characters and recruitment mechanic for enhancing replayability, while others criticize the lack of depth in character interactions and repetitive missions. While the game offers potential for replay value with its open world and unique systems, improvements in mission variety and character development could elevate the experience. Ultimately, individual preferences will determine the game's replay value.