Critics have mixed feelings about the storytelling in Olija. Some praise its engaging narrative and emotional depth, while others criticize its lack of context and underdeveloped aspects. Overall, opinions vary on whether the game effectively conveys its mysterious and intriguing story.

Critics rave about Olija's innovative combat mechanics, exploration elements, and harpoon gameplay. Praise for its satisfying action, engaging RPG elements, and dynamic combat. Some critics note limited depth and variety in gameplay elements, like repetitive boss battles and lack of enemy challenge. Overall, Olija offers a compelling and engaging gameplay experience with unique twists and satisfying combat, despite some minor flaws.

Critics generally praise Olija for its unique and detailed art style, rich environments, and immersive animations, likening it to classic sidescrollers. Some critics have concerns about enemies blending in and retro graphics making gameplay harder, but overall, Olija's visual design is considered a standout feature that successfully blends retro aesthetics with modern flair to create a visually striking and immersive world.

Critics overwhelmingly praise Olija for its immersive sound design and atmospheric music, enhancing the gameplay experience. While some find certain aspects overstated or forgettable, the consensus is that Olija excels in creating an immersive and atmospheric world through its soundscapes and music, contributing significantly to its success.

In Olija, critics have mixed feelings about the voice acting. Some praised the unique character voices and atmospheric quality, while others disliked it, suggesting it should have been eliminated. Overall, opinions lean slightly towards the positive side, with varying views on specific elements like the gibberish language. Despite differing opinions, most critics agree that the voice acting enhances the game's atmosphere and adds to its mystery.

Olija's technical performance received mixed feedback from critics across different gaming platforms. While the PS4 and Xbox One versions showed stability and improvements post-patch, the Nintendo Switch and PC versions faced issues like slowdowns, crashes, and bugs during gameplay. Despite some platforms showing enhancements, technical hiccups affected the overall gameplay experience on multiple platforms, leaving room for improvement in Olija's performance.

Critics praise Olija for its crafting, collectibles, and unique hats that offer varied playstyles but criticize its short length and lack of incentives for replay. While some find its charm and polished adventure appealing, opinions on its replay value are mixed, with varying perspectives on its ability to draw players back for multiple playthroughs.