Critics are divided on South Park: Snow Day! Some praise its irreverent humor and originality, while others find it lacking the iconic humor and memorable moments of the series. Overall, the game struggles to deliver the sharp satire and engagement of previous titles, leaving a lukewarm impression on reviewers.

Critics have mixed feelings about South Park: Snow Day! Positive aspects include a card-based system and engaging co-op play, but the game falls short with repetitive combat, dull mechanics, and lack of depth. Critics point out issues like floaty movement, imprecise controls, and lack of variety in weapons and skills. While some unique elements are appreciated, overall, the game fails to deliver an immersive and exciting gameplay experience, leaving players wanting more innovation and excitement.

Critics are divided on the graphics of South Park: Snow Day! Some praise the transition to 3D visuals for its smoothness and unique aesthetics, while others criticize it for lacking distinctiveness and vibrancy compared to previous games. Overall, opinions on the visual design range from appreciation for its charm and humor to concerns about bland environments and lack of variety.

Critics had mixed feelings about the sound design and music in South Park: Snow Day! Some praised the strong voice acting and impressive soundtrack for enhancing the gameplay experience, while others criticized the lack of impact and variety in sound design. Despite some dated humor elements, the game generally received a somewhat positive reception for capturing the essence of South Park through its audio elements. Overall, there were areas for improvement, but the voice acting and music were highlighted as strengths by many reviewers.

Critics have mixed feelings about the voice acting in South Park: Snow Day! Some praise Trey Parker and Matt Stone's performances for staying true to the show's style and adding authenticity, while others criticize the repetitive voice lines and lackluster humor. Overall, most reviewers appreciate the voice acting for capturing the essence of South Park characters and contributing to the comedic tone of the game, despite some shortcomings.

Critics had mixed reactions to the technical performance of the game on different platforms. Xbox Series X received praise for stability but was criticized for AI and collision issues. Nintendo Switch faced significant technical problems, except for Pocket Tactics, which had a smooth experience. PlayStation 5 and PC platforms generally had smooth gameplay, but some critics noted specific technical issues. Overall, most platforms had stable performance, with occasional issues reported.

Critics are divided on the replay value of South Park: Snow Day! Some praise the multiplayer feature and variety of gameplay options for enhancing replayability, while others criticize the repetitive nature and lack of depth as limiting factors. Overall, the general consensus is that the game may offer some replayability through certain aspects, but falls short of providing a truly engaging and compelling experience for players looking for long-term enjoyment.