Critics mostly love the story of Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy for its thrilling cases, well-written characters, and exploration of dark themes. While some point out pacing issues and narrative flaws, the majority agree that it's a compelling and engaging narrative with impactful twists. Overall, the story receives high praise for its strengths, making it a standout feature of the game.

Critics praise the engaging gameplay of Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy, particularly highlighting the entertaining courtroom phase and new gameplay elements like Athena's AI companion. While some critics have mixed opinions on certain mechanics, the majority agree that the gameplay is very good, with innovative features keeping the experience fresh and inviting creative thinking. Overall, the consensus is that the game offers a great blend of puzzle-solving, drama, and mystery, making it a must-play for fans of the series.

Critics generally praise the upgraded visuals in Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy, highlighting fully-rendered 3D environments, high-definition graphics, and vibrant colors. Some prefer the original 2D art, noting issues with 3D models and textures. Overall, critics agree that the visual enhancements enhance the game's experience.

Critics praise Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy's Sound Design and Music, highlighting features like the Orchestra Hall, jukebox, and media player for an immersive experience. They commend the rearranged soundtrack but note issues with sound mixing and lack of certain features. Overall, the music is excellent, enhancing gameplay despite minor drawbacks, according to critics.

Critics are divided on the voice acting in Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy. Some praise the fresh voice dubs and recasting of main dialogues, while others criticize the lack of voice overs or limited voice acting. The game offers English and Japanese voice options, enhancing accessibility. Overall, opinions vary, with some finding value in the voice acting despite its inconsistencies.

Critics had mixed opinions on the technical performance of Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy across different platforms. Positives included enhanced visuals and smooth gameplay on PS4, Xbox One, and PC, while negatives included quality of life issues on PC and technical limitations on Switch. Overall, critics found the performance generally positive with some minor fixable issues, praising the faithful reproductions of the original titles and enhanced experiences on consoles.

Critics generally praise Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy for its strong replay value, citing additional content like DLC cases and extras that enhance the gaming experience. Some critics mention the linear storytelling as a downside to replayability, but overall, the majority highlight the various features that make the game worth playing again.