Critics have mixed opinions on the story of Silent Hope. Positive reviews praise its engaging elements and heartwarming nature, while negative feedback criticizes its simplicity and lack of player involvement. Some find the background story intriguing, while others feel the narrative lacks depth. Overall, the story serves as a backdrop to the gameplay, offering charm and intrigue despite not being a standout feature.

Critics have mixed opinions on Silent Hope's gameplay. Positive aspects praised by some include variety in playable characters, addictive dungeon crawling, and well-balanced combat. However, others criticize it for being simple, repetitive, and lacking variation. Overall, while some appreciate the strengths in gameplay, others point out weaknesses like easy combat and tedious gameplay. The consensus leans slightly towards the positive side, with some critics finding it fun, addictive, and offering varied combat experiences.

Critics love the adorable chibi-style art and cute characters in Silent Hope, praising its charming visuals that fit the dungeon-crawling theme perfectly. While some critics mention minor flaws like lack of variation and sluggish combat, the overall consensus is that the game's graphics are modern, colorful, and enhance the charming atmosphere of the game.

Critics praise Silent Hope's sound design and music for its varied and memorable soundtrack, fitting music for dungeon exploration, and sharp sound effects. The Princess' guiding voice is admired, but some find repetitive audio lines and music a drawback. Overall, critics view the sound design and music as a strong suit that enhances the gameplay experience.

Critics have mixed opinions on the voice acting in Silent Hope. Some praise the English voice actress for the princess, while others criticize the lack of voice acting for most characters and repetitive dialogue. Overall, there is room for improvement in the voice acting of the game, with both positive and negative aspects highlighted by critics.

Critics mostly praised Silent Hope for its smooth performance on Nintendo Switch and PC, with minimal issues like occasional input lag on the Switch. The game runs well on both platforms, maintaining steady framerates and providing an enjoyable gaming experience overall.

Critics are split on the replay value of Silent Hope, with some praising its multiple playable characters and diverse outcomes, while others criticize its lack of challenge and potential for redundancy. While some appreciate the game's additional content and unlockable hard mode, others feel that grinding for materials and waiting detracts from the overall experience. Overall, Silent Hope offers replay value for niche players who enjoy grinding and exploration, but may not appeal to a broader audience due to its limitations.