Critics have mixed opinions on the story of Starfield. Some praise its intriguing elements, engaging narrative, well-written dialogue, and unique characters. Others criticize its lack of depth, reliance on sci-fi tropes, and clichéd main story. While some appreciate the ambitious themes and worldbuilding, others feel the story lacks originality and character development. In conclusion, Starfield's story has moments of brilliance but also room for improvement, with both strengths and weaknesses highlighted by different critics.

Critics have mixed opinions on Starfield's gameplay. Praise for engaging combat and customization options, but criticism for repetitive activities and mediocre combat and movement systems. Overall, the game offers diverse gameplay possibilities, with strong gunplay and customization, but falls short in some areas like skill unlocking and AI. Despite flaws, many find Starfield's gameplay immersive and comprehensive.

Starfield's graphics impress with detailed cities, diverse environments, and immersive world design, earning praise for its scale and retro-futuristic aesthetic. While critics note graphical issues and lack of variety in exploration, the game's visuals fall short in character designs and animations. Overall, Starfield's visuals shine, marking a generational leap for Bethesda despite some room for improvement.

Critics rave about Starfield's sound design and music, with praise for its superb orchestral score that sets a thrilling tone for the game. Positive feedback from various sources showcases the excellence of the music in capturing space's excitement and awe. No negative comments suggest a well-received soundtrack overall, though more diverse opinions could provide a fuller analysis. Overall, critics agree that Starfield's sound design and music are top-notch, enhancing the gaming experience with engaging tunes and atmospheric sounds.

Critics mostly praise Starfield's voice acting for its enjoyable fully voiced dialogue, authentic performances, and memorable characters. Positive reviews note the personal touch of characters calling the player by name and Jake Green's standout performance as Vasco. However, some critics criticize the flat voice acting and banal dialogue, suggesting room for improvement in character animations. Overall, while Starfield's voice acting has strengths like superb performances, there are areas that could be enhanced for a better player experience.

Starfield's technical performance on PC shows some bugs and issues, but it launches almost bug-free, surprising for a Bethesda game. On Xbox Series X, there are varied opinions with some critics noting frame drops and glitches, while others praise its stability. Overall, critics find Starfield relatively bug-free and stable, delivering a satisfactory technical performance on both platforms.

Critics are raving about Starfield's replay value, praising its vast universe, gripping stories, and multiple playthrough options. Despite some minor criticisms about ignored features and frustrating mechanics, the majority agree that the game offers endless exploration opportunities and engaging gameplay. With New Game Plus options and choices with repercussions, Starfield is hailed as a must-play title with excellent replayability potential, drawing comparisons to beloved classics like Skyrim and Fallout 4.