Critics' opinions on Bayonetta 2's story are all over the map. Some praise the absurd, captivating narrative with unexpected twists, while others criticize it for lacking coherence and having nonsensical dialogue. Despite mixed reviews, most agree that the story adds depth to the game and enhances the outlandish battles Bayonetta faces. Love it or hate it, the story is a key part of the game's charm and overall experience.

Critics rave about Bayonetta 2's gameplay, praising its action-packed combat, flashy combos, and depth. The addition of new moves and weapons enhances the experience, with the combat system being a standout feature. While some mention a lack of innovation and a learning curve, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the game's exceptional quality and immersive gameplay.

Critics overwhelmingly praise Bayonetta 2 for its stunning visuals, vibrant colors, and impressive character designs, with detailed environments and pixel-perfect animations. While some critics note rough textures and technical issues, the majority agree that the game's unique art style, combining demonic angels and witches, and overall visual improvement from its predecessor make it visually appealing and one of the best-looking games on the Nintendo Switch.

Critics overwhelmingly praise Bayonetta 2's sound design and music, highlighting the standout soundtrack featuring pop and classical music, professional voice acting, and popular songs like "Moon River." The game's audio elements are described as excellent, maintaining the series' quality standards without any notable flaws.

Critics are split on the voice acting in Bayonetta 2. Some praise it for high quality and strong performances, especially for lead character Bayonetta, while others find the characters unlikeable and the dialogue nonsensical. Overall, opinions vary, but most critics acknowledge the talent and charisma of the voice actors involved, with some standout performances alongside a few shortcomings.

Critics lauded Bayonetta 2 on the Nintendo Switch for its smooth performance, stable 60 fps, enhanced visuals, faster load times, and reduced frame rate drops. Some minor drawbacks included occasional lag, imprecise touchscreen controls, and slight visual quality decrease on a TV. Overall, reviewers agree that the game's technical performance on the Switch is top-notch, offering an enjoyable and technically impressive experience for players.

Critics praise Bayonetta 2 for its high replay value due to additional content, multiplayer modes, and challenging gameplay. Some critics mention the lack of new content in the Nintendo Switch version, but overall, the game's worthiness of replaying is emphasized.