In Mario vs. Donkey Kong, critics have differing views on the story. Some praise its bizarre and hilarious nature, while others find it simplistic and lacking depth. The narrative follows Mario chasing Donkey Kong to recover stolen toys, offering a straightforward premise that sets the stage for gameplay. While some critics feel the story lacks complexity and surprises, most agree that it effectively serves its purpose within the game, providing a cohesive structure for players to engage with. Overall, the story complements the arcade-style gameplay and captures the essence of the Mario vs. Donkey Kong franchise.

Critics love the engaging gameplay of Mario vs. Donkey Kong, praising its challenging yet fair puzzles and platforming. Some minor issues with controls and collision detection were noted, but overall, the game offers a satisfying experience with varied challenges and rewarding level designs. Despite a few technical hiccups, Mario vs. Donkey Kong stands out as a top-notch puzzle-platformer that caters to players of all ages and skill levels.

Critics rave about the eye-catching graphics and visual overhaul in Mario vs. Donkey Kong, praising the detailed levels, vibrant colors, and improved character animations. While some critics feel the updates lack a unique charm or modernization in certain aspects, the majority applaud the game's stunning visuals that blend nostalgia with contemporary elements. Overall, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with critics highlighting the game's charming aesthetic and enhanced visual experience on the Nintendo Switch.

Critics rave about the Sound Design and Music of Mario vs. Donkey Kong, praising the revamped soundtrack with live instrumentals and iconic voice acting by Charles Martinet for Mario. Some critics noted drawbacks like repetitive audio, but overall, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers appreciating the immersive music that enhances gameplay and sets the tone for the rivalry between Mario and Donkey Kong.

Critics had mixed views on the voice acting in Mario vs. Donkey Kong. Some praised Charles Martinet's portrayal of Mario for adding charm, while others felt the remake missed the mark compared to the original. Despite differing opinions, most agreed that Martinet's performance enhanced the game's authenticity and appeal.

Critics mostly praised Mario vs. Donkey Kong on the Nintendo Switch for its smooth 60fps gameplay and flawless performance in both docked and handheld modes. Some critics did mention issues with controls and Mario's responsiveness, but overall, the consensus is positive, with the game delivering a polished and visually appealing experience with room for technical improvements.

Reviewers praise Mario vs. Donkey Kong for its diverse challenges, modes, and content that boost replayability, including time attacks and co-op play. Some critics mention repetitive gameplay and limited appeal, but overall, the game offers decent to good replay value with incentives for players to revisit levels and engage in new challenges.