Sonic Superstars

The storyline of Sonic Superstars has received mixed reviews from critics. Positively, many reviewers appreciated the classic Sonic elements and the introduction of new characters, such as Fang the Hunter and Trip, adding depth and variety to the narrative. Critics like Atomix and Cultured Vultures praised the game for taking the series back to basics with familiar Sonic tropes like Dr. Eggman's villainy and the quest for the Chaos Emeralds. Additionally, the hand-drawn art style and animated sequences, as highlighted by COGconnected, were commended for their excellent presentation reminiscent of 90s cartoons, enhancing the overall storytelling experience. On the flip side, some critics pointed out the simplicity and lack of depth in the storyline of Sonic Superstars. MeuPlayStation noted the story's simplistic presentation with minimal emotional appeal, relying heavily on nostalgia rather than direct dialogues to connect with the characters. Critics like IGN highlighted the disappointment in the choice to focus more on platforming over speed, which may have detracted from the overall excitement and engagement of the narrative. Furthermore, reviewers like The Jimquisition and Ragequit.gr mentioned the lack of major twists or complexities in the plot, indicating a somewhat predictable and straightforward storyline that may not offer much in terms of surprises or innovation. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the story of Sonic Superstars leans towards a nostalgic and straightforward narrative that blends classic Sonic elements with some new character introductions. While some reviewers appreciated the game's return to basics and the charming presentation of the storyline, others felt that it lacked depth and originality, relying too heavily on established tropes without offering significant new twists. Despite the mixed opinions on the depth and complexity of the plot, most critics acknowledged the game's ability to cater to fans of the franchise looking for a familiar yet enjoyable Sonic adventure.

The gameplay of Sonic Superstars has received praise for blending classic 2D Sonic gameplay with modern elements, introducing new abilities tied to Chaos Emeralds, and offering distinct character abilities that influence gameplay. Critics like Meristation and IGN Adria appreciate the fast-paced and addictive nature of the gameplay, with well-designed levels, multiple playable characters, and the addition of new mechanics like Emerald Powers. The game successfully captures the essence of classic Sonic adventures while adding depth and variety to the gameplay through unique character abilities and power-ups. On the flip side, some critics have pointed out shortcomings in the gameplay of Sonic Superstars. Issues with level design, cheap hits, uninspired gimmicks, and tedious boss battles have been highlighted by reviewers like Destructoid and Vooks. The game is criticized for introducing unnecessary features, slower pacing compared to other Sonic titles, and frustrating boss encounters that disrupt the flow of gameplay. Additionally, some critics mention underutilized abilities, overly long levels, and difficulty spikes as areas that detract from the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the gameplay of Sonic Superstars is mixed. While some reviewers appreciate the game's faithful recreation of classic Sonic gameplay with new mechanics and abilities, others find flaws in level design, boss battles, and certain gameplay mechanics. The balance between nostalgia and originality, the variety of playable characters, and the blend of old and new elements seem to be points of contention among critics. Despite some criticisms, the game is generally praised for its fast-paced platforming, diverse stages, and engaging boss battles, offering a modernized take on traditional 2D Sonic gameplay that caters to both classic and contemporary tastes.

The Graphics and Visual Design of Sonic Superstars have received a mix of positive feedback from critics. Many reviewers praised the game for its vibrant colors, detailed character designs, and expressive animations that bring the world to life. Critics like Vandal appreciated the beautiful, colorful, and vibrant environments, while Finger Guns described the visuals as sumptuous with well-executed character movements. The game successfully captures the essence of the classic Sonic franchise with modernized visual aesthetics, as noted by Nintendo Life, Movies Games and Tech, and Push Square. The transition to a 3D look with 2D elements was also commended by Wccftech and Checkpoint Gaming for maintaining the charm of the original games while introducing refreshing visuals. On the other hand, some critics highlighted certain drawbacks in the Graphics and Visual Design of Sonic Superstars. IGN Adria and Gameblog.fr criticized the game for showing flaws over time, with inconsistencies in level quality and graphics, lacking detail, innovation, and precision in controls. NintendoWorldReport and Forbes pointed out issues with the camera being too close to Sonic, leading to a claustrophobic and cluttered design with critical details often off-screen. TheSixthAxis mentioned background repetition and level design issues, while Game Informer highlighted unexpected hazards that could be frustrating due to the fast-paced nature of the game. These criticisms indicate areas where Sonic Superstars could improve in terms of graphics and visual presentation. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Sonic Superstars leans towards a positive reception. While there are some criticisms regarding inconsistencies in level quality, camera issues, and lack of innovation in certain aspects, the majority of reviewers appreciate the game's ability to blend the classic Sonic aesthetic with modern visuals. The game's vibrant colors, detailed character designs, and expressive animations have been widely praised, creating a visually appealing experience for players. Sonic Superstars successfully captures the essence of the beloved franchise while introducing new elements that enhance the overall visual presentation, making it an enjoyable and visually attractive game for fans of the series.

The opinions on the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Superstars are quite varied among the critics. Many reviewers praised the soundtrack for its nostalgic elements and catchy tunes. Digital Chumps described it as "praised for being nearly perfect and clicking with the nostalgic sounds of older Sonic games," while Game Informer mentioned that there are a couple of standout tracks. IGN also commended the music, stating that it matches the theme of each stage perfectly and provides an enjoyable experience with percussive and electronic beats. Critics like GAMINGbible and PlaySense appreciated the upbeat and fitting Sonic music that added to the overall experience. On the other hand, some critics were less impressed with the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Superstars. GGRecon found the soundtrack to be grating and irritating, with tracks restarting after regular deaths, while GamingBolt considered it one of the worst in the franchise with poor mixing. MeuPlayStation and Noisy Pixel both expressed disappointment in the soundtrack, with MeuPlayStation mentioning that it hindered player concentration rather than enhancing the experience. Nintendojo and NintendoWorldReport felt that the music fell short of classic Sonic soundtracks, lacking the energy and complexity of the best Sonic songs. Overall, the consensus among the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Superstars leans towards the positive side, with many appreciating the nostalgic feel and catchy tunes that enhance the gameplay experience. Critics like Digital Chumps, IGN, and Pure Nintendo highlighted the strengths of the soundtrack in capturing the essence of older Sonic games and providing memorable tracks. However, there were also criticisms regarding the lackluster tracks, poor mixing, and repetitive nature of some music, as pointed out by GamingBolt and GGRecon. Despite the mixed feedback, the majority of critics found the music to be a significant aspect of the game that added to the overall enjoyment, with some standout tracks that resonated well with the Sonic franchise's legacy.

Summary unavailable

In terms of the technical performance on the PlayStation 5, Sonic Superstars received mostly positive feedback. Critics like Everyeye.it and GamesRadar+ praised the game for running smoothly at a consistent 60 frames-per-second (fps) with responsive controls and no major issues mentioned. Additionally, CGMagazine noted minor slowdowns but an overall locked framerate. TheGamer even went as far as calling it the best-performing Sonic game at launch in some time, highlighting the game's optimization for the PS5 platform. On the flip side, some critics did point out certain drawbacks in the technical performance of Sonic Superstars on the PS5. IGN Adria criticized the game for technical issues related to the Unity engine and the battle mode, while Hardcore Gamer mentioned collision issues and camera problems affecting the multiplayer co-op experience. PlaySense and Press Start Australia also highlighted occasional framerate drops, wonky hit detection, and long load times as areas of concern. These criticisms indicate that while the game generally runs well on the PS5, there are still some technical hiccups that need addressing. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the technical performance of Sonic Superstars across all platforms is relatively positive, with most reviewers acknowledging smooth gameplay at 60fps and stable performance. However, there are mixed opinions on specific platforms. While the PS5 version generally received praise for its smooth performance, some critics raised concerns about technical issues like framerate drops and collision problems. On the other hand, the Nintendo Switch version was commended for running wonderfully with rock-solid framerates but faced occasional crashes in online sessions. By considering the feedback from critics like Forbes, who mentioned jerky loading screen animations on the PS5, and Nintendo Life, who noted occasional crashes on the Switch, it's evident that Sonic Superstars delivers a solid technical experience overall but may benefit from further optimization and bug fixes on certain platforms.

In terms of positives, Sonic Superstars offers a variety of elements that contribute to its replay value. Critics like IGN and Hobby Consolas highlight the inclusion of collectibles such as Chaos Emeralds and medals, which encourage exploration and multiple playthroughs. The game features multiple characters with unique abilities, special and bonus stages, and hidden secrets that add depth to the gameplay experience. Additionally, the inclusion of multiplayer modes like co-op and battle mode, as mentioned by GAMINGbible and Pure Xbox, provides additional avenues for players to enjoy the game beyond the main story. On the negative side, several critics point out aspects of Sonic Superstars that hinder its replay value. Destructoid, Gameblog.fr, and NintendoWorldReport criticize the multiplayer experience for being underdeveloped, limiting content, and lacking depth. Issues with the battle mode, as highlighted by Game Informer and Vandal, are noted as being shallow and uninteresting, which may deter players from engaging with this aspect of the game. Furthermore, some reviewers mention tedious boss battles, poorly integrated superpowers, and lackluster online modes as factors contributing to the game's low replayability. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the replay value of Sonic Superstars is mixed. While the game offers various elements like collectibles, multiple characters, and hidden secrets that enhance replayability, there are significant drawbacks such as underdeveloped multiplayer modes and unengaging battle mechanics that impact the overall experience. Critics like Vgames and TierraGamer highlight the game's shortcomings in terms of variety and lasting appeal compared to other titles in the Sonic series. Despite some positive aspects, the general sentiment suggests that Sonic Superstars falls short in fully delivering on its potential for long-term engagement and replay value.