Critics are divided on the story of Super Mario Bros. Wonder. Some praise its charm and new characters, while others find it forgettable and overshadowed by gameplay. Overall, the story's impact is mixed, with gameplay being the main focus for most critics.

Critics rave about the gameplay of Super Mario Bros. Wonder, praising its nostalgic yet fresh feel, innovative power-ups, and versatile mechanics. The game offers polished, player-empowering experiences with inventive platforming, creative levels, and a variety of gameplay styles. Despite minor criticisms like limited badge equipping and varying difficulty levels, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, applauding the game for breaking traditional 2D Mario boundaries and delivering an enjoyable, exciting platforming adventure.

Critics overwhelmingly praise Super Mario Bros. Wonder for its stunning visuals, vibrant colors, and expressive art direction, with many commending the game's beautiful graphics and attention to detail. Some minor criticism about level cohesion exists, but overall, the consensus is that the game's graphics are exceptional, bringing the Flower Kingdom to life with visually delightful and wonderful designs.

Critics mostly love the Sound Design and Music of Super Mario Bros. Wonder, praising its catchy tunes, immersive experience, and charming details. Positive feedback highlights the game's lively atmosphere and sensory delight. While some critics find the music forgettable, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive. Critics like VG247 and Gamereactor UK specifically commend the game's audio elements.

Critics generally praise the voice acting in Super Mario Bros. Wonder, highlighting the new actors' respectful portrayal of characters like Mario and Luigi. While some note a lack of previous enthusiasm, the consensus leans positive, with many appreciating the expressive characters and inoffensive nature of the talking flowers. Overall, the voice acting is seen as a strong aspect of the game, though not all critics delve deeply into this aspect in their reviews.

Critics unanimously rave about Super Mario Bros. Wonder's flawless technical performance on the Nintendo Switch, praising its smooth gameplay, stunning visuals, and bug-free experience. No technical issues were reported, making it a standout masterpiece in terms of performance.

Critics generally praise the replay value of Super Mario Bros. Wonder for its hidden levels, collectibles, multiple playable characters, and online multiplayer. Some express concerns about limited worlds and lack of incentives to replay. Overall, the game offers diverse experiences and incentives for exploration, making it engaging and worth returning to for many players.