Critics generally praise Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order for its engaging narrative exploring familiar themes and character growth. The story is described as exciting and thrilling, delving into Jedi Purge consequences and themes of redemption. While some find it formulaic and slow to start, most agree it offers an enjoyable experience with strong character development and well-defined threats. Overall, the game's story is seen as a standout in the Star Wars universe, blending emotional depth and cinematic quality.

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order's gameplay earned high praise for its tactical lightsaber combat reminiscent of Dark Souls and Sekiro. Critics lauded the combat's depth and challenge, though some criticized the platforming puzzles and lack of exploration rewards. Overall, the game offers a satisfying experience with minor flaws, making it a must-play for Star Wars and action-adventure fans.

Critics mostly love the stunning graphics and visual design of Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, praising its cinematic presentation and attention to detail. The game's environments are particularly lauded for capturing the Star Wars aesthetic. Some critics did mention technical issues like glitches and texture problems, but overall, the consensus is that the game offers an impressive visual experience that immerses players in the Star Wars universe.

Critics rave about the sound design and music in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, praising its authentic Star Wars experience with great voice acting, familiar sound effects, and a John Williams-styled orchestra. Despite some minor critiques of non-traditional music, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, making it a must-play for Star Wars fans.

Critics overwhelmingly praise the voice acting in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, highlighting great performances by the cast. While some critics have reservations about the protagonist's voice acting, the overall sentiment remains positive. The majority agrees that the voice acting adds depth and charm to the game's characters, making it a standout feature.

Critics praised PlayStation 5 for improved load times and smooth gameplay, while Xbox One X had no major issues. However, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions faced technical problems like stuttering, frame rate drops, and long loading times. PC version also had performance issues, but could be fixed with updates. Overall, consoles struggled with technical issues, but potential for patches to improve performance mentioned by critics.

Critics generally praise Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order for its replay value, citing enjoyable exploration, backtracking with new skills, secret items, and collectibles. Positive aspects like substantial playtime and challenging boss fights enhance replayability. However, some critics criticize the lack of character progression and meaningful exploration, as well as issues with fast travel and excessive collectibles. Despite these drawbacks, the consensus is that the game offers a decent level of replay value with rewarding backtracking and engaging gameplay elements.