Critics are divided on Death Stranding's story. Some praise its depth and uniqueness, while others criticize its complexity and heavy-handed exposition. Some commend its deep and engaging narrative, while others find it needlessly confusing and repetitive. The storytelling is described as both brilliant and convoluted, with themes of connection and rebuilding in a post-apocalyptic world. Overall, opinions are mixed, with some praising its twists and turns, while others find it lacking in depth and subtlety.

Critics have mixed opinions on Death Stranding's gameplay. Some praise its fun, challenging mechanics and strategic exploration, while others criticize its frustrating core mechanics, tedious quests, and lack of depth. Overall, the game offers a unique experience with rewarding aspects like weight management and environmental hurdles, but some find it repetitive and lacking in certain areas.

Critics overwhelmingly praised Death Stranding's graphics and visual design on PC, lauding stunning landscapes, lifelike character models, and vibrant environments. The game's high-tech aesthetic and use of DLSS technology were commended, despite some minor criticisms about dated textures and structure degradation. Overall, reviewers were impressed by the enhancements in the PC version and considered the visuals to be a standout feature of the game.

Critics rave about Death Stranding's sound design and music, praising the stunning original score and mood-enhancing soundtrack. While some mention the lack of specific details, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive. The haunting music by Low Roar and the ethereal atmosphere it creates have been lauded by various critics, highlighting the game's immersive audio experience.

Some critics praise the star-studded cast for their engaging performances in Death Stranding, while others criticize aspects like the lack of content for the protagonist and dialogue quality. Overall, opinions on the voice acting are mixed, with positive reviews highlighting exceptional performances and negative reviews pointing out shortcomings. The talent and chemistry of the cast bring both immersive moments and room for improvement in the game.

Critics lauded Death Stranding's technical performance across all platforms, with the PC version receiving praise for refined graphics and improved performance. While some noted control issues and demanding hardware requirements, overall sentiment was positive, highlighting smooth gameplay and high frame rates. The PC version was commended by critics for its flexibility and cutting-edge features, solidifying its positive reception.

Critics have mixed opinions on the replay value of Death Stranding. Some praise its strategic elements and multiplayer features for enhancing replayability, while others feel it lacks new content. Ultimately, whether the game is worth replaying depends on individual preferences and expectations.