The Last of Us Part II Remastered's story is hailed for its emotional impact and compelling narrative by most critics, exploring themes of trauma, revenge, and morality. While some critics have concerns about certain elements and storytelling, the majority praise it as a masterclass in storytelling with deep exploration of humanity and forgiveness, making it a standout title in the gaming world.

Critics mostly praise The Last of Us Part II Remastered gameplay enhancements like 'No Return' mode and new features for adding replay value and variety. Some critics have concerns about potential repetitiveness in the new modes, but overall, the consensus is positive with appreciation for improvements, engaging mechanics, and the game's seamless blend of narrative and gameplay.

Critics overwhelmingly praised the stunning graphics and visual design of The Last of Us Part II Remastered, with enhanced visuals like improved textures, animations, and lighting effects. While some critics found the upgrades underwhelming, most appreciated the enhanced immersion and technical achievements on the PlayStation 5. Despite mixed opinions, the consensus leans towards a highly positive evaluation of the graphical improvements in the remastered version.

Critics raved about the Sound Design and Music of The Last of Us Part II Remastered, loving the immersive experience created by voice acting, sound effects, and music. The DualSense support impressed with haptic feedback, but some found it overwhelming. While some critics felt the music was too subdued, the majority praised the overall impact. The Guitar Free Play mode added a unique touch. Despite minor criticisms, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with the sound design and music enhancing the emotional impact and gameplay depth of the game.

Critics unanimously praised the exceptional voice acting in The Last of Us Part II Remastered, highlighting the strong performances that brought the characters to life. Positive feedback emphasized the depth, emotion, and quality of the voice performances, with no discernible negative opinions from critics. The voice acting was lauded as a standout aspect of the game, contributing significantly to its immersive storytelling and character development.

Critics raved about The Last of Us Part II Remastered on PS5, applauding super-fast loading times, smooth framerate, and adaptive triggers. While some noted limitations like lack of 120Hz support, overall consensus was overwhelmingly positive for its technical performance and enhanced visual fidelity across platforms.

Critics praise The Last of Us Part II Remastered for its enhanced replay value with new modes and content like No Return and customization options, offering fans fresh experiences. Some critics express concerns about certain modes feeling derivative or losing charm quickly, potentially limiting long-term appeal. Overall, the game successfully enriches replay value, appealing to existing fans and providing incentives to revisit, despite some reservations about certain modes.