Critics overwhelmingly praised Senua's Saga: Hellblade II for its deep emotional impact, exploration of mental health themes, and engaging storytelling. Many lauded its narrative depth, character development, and incorporation of Norse mythology. However, some critics raised concerns about pacing and narrative inconsistencies. Overall, the majority of reviewers found the story compelling and impactful, with Senua's journey through trauma and self-discovery leaving a lasting impression.

Critics are divided on the gameplay of Senua's Saga: Hellblade II. Some praise its visceral combat, exploration, and puzzles, citing improvements in mechanics and variety in enemies. Others criticize the repetitive combat, uninteresting puzzles, and lack of innovation. Positive feedback from some is balanced by negative comments from others, resulting in a mixed consensus on the overall gameplay experience.

Critics rave about the stunning graphics and visual design of Senua's Saga: Hellblade II, calling it a masterpiece in the gaming world. Praise for its realistic environments, exquisite lighting, and breathtaking landscapes inspired by Iceland. Some minor criticisms include technical issues and dark scenes needing adjustment. Overall, critics agree that the game sets a new standard for visual excellence with next-gen graphics and high-fidelity visuals, making it a standout experience in the industry.

Critics unanimously praise the exceptional sound design and music in Senua's Saga: Hellblade II, with haunting melodies, binaural audio, and Andy LaPlegua's score adding to the immersive experience. While some critics had minor criticisms, overall the audio design was lauded for its industry-leading quality. The consensus is that the sound design and music are vital in enhancing the immersive experience of the game, with reviewers recommending playing with headphones for full impact.

Critics rave about Melina Juergens' exceptional voice acting as Senua in Senua's Saga: Hellblade II, praising her for conveying a wide range of emotions and enhancing the game's emotional depth. While some critics note a slight imbalance in the quality of supporting cast performances, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive. Reviewers highlight the standout voice acting as a major strength, with many emphasizing its significant contribution to the storytelling and immersive experience of the game.

Critics praised Senua's Saga: Hellblade II on Xbox Series X for its stunning visuals and smooth gameplay powered by Unreal Engine 5, though some noted technical issues like frame rate restrictions and visual drawbacks. Overall, it's lauded for its immersive experience on both Xbox Series X and PC platforms, with minor hitches but solid performance.

Critics praise Senua's Saga: Hellblade II for its immersive storytelling and emotional experience, as well as collectibles and exploration elements that boost replay value. However, concerns about repetitive puzzles, limited gameplay progression, and lack of creativity may hinder replayability. Overall, while some aspects enhance replay value, the game falls short in providing substantial reasons for extensive replayability, with criticisms outweighing the positives.